News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Friday March 05, 2010 @07:26PM (#1170892)
Skin color isn't any more an indicator of class than shoe size or fingernail length. To show this, one need only think about the consequences of skin color actually being an indicator of class.

Given a random sampling among a race, if skin color was an accurate indicator of class, you should be able to predict the same class (other than middle class) for each sample, and ultimately be right more than you were wrong. But you can't: http://www.census.gov/prod/2009pubs/p60-236.pdf

Furthermore, I posit that class isn't even a predictor of behavior in the macro-sense. That is, across all classes the proportion of people who behave foolishly, is a constant. The difference money makes is in the degree of associated risk with the behaviors that occur, not in the number of occurrences of the behaviors themselves.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by natrius on Friday March 05, 2010 @07:57PM (#1170927)
In America, skin color is a good predictor of class. The barometer isn't being right more than you're wrong; it's being more accurate than assuming everyone earns the average income. You will be able to make a more accurate guess of an American's income if you know their race.

When you add in clothing, hair and accent, it'd be pretty difficult to misidentify someone's class, or more importantly, culture. Identifying members of subcultures with criminal tendencies is a skill that anyone who has walked around in a city late at night has put to use.

Class isn't a great predictor of behavior, but culture is. Moreover, I think it's safe to assume that people with lower incomes commit violent crime, for instance, at a higher rate than the rest of society. All other things being equal, the better the risk to reward ratio of an action, the more likely someone is to take it.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Friday March 05, 2010 @08:43PM (#1170983)
A "good" predictor must be useful, correct? Well, then how can it be useful if it is wrong more than it is right....?

Simply stated, being right more than one is wrong is the same thing as being more accurate than a random assignment (as we approach a large number of "trials") if the outcomes are equally likely. And that is the point - race tells you nothing more significant about class then guessing does (if we remove 'middle class' as a selection), and class tells you nothing significant about behavior.

Also, you seem to be conflating 'class' and 'culture' now. Culture is a much, much better indicator of behavior than class, as culture speaks to beliefs and value judgements. As such, they are not interchangable ideas (that is, the propostion that 'Skin color is a good predictor of culture' is not the same as the one you made prior, 'Skin color is a good predictor of class' - but is probably just as fallacious).

Clothing and hair (God only knows what you meant by 'accent.' Care to clarify?) in isolation are strong enough indicators of culture, that race quite literally adds nothing to their accuracy - the same can be said of 'style of dress' and 'price of car driven,' for class. Race is superfluous.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by natrius on Friday March 05, 2010 @09:18PM (#1171022)
"And that is the point - race tells you nothing more significant about class then guessing does"

That's just mathematically incorrect. Different races have different average incomes. If you guess that average for each person, you'll be more accurate than guessing the overall average for everyone. If you're measuring at such a coarse level as upper/middle/lower class, then sure, that doesn't help. Since we're not relying on race alone, we don't need that kind of accuracy.

"Also, you seem to be conflating 'class' and 'culture' now."

I don't think culture and class are interchangeable. I think class is an indicator of culture, which I would then use to predict someone's behavior. I probably should've made that clear earlier. In America, any skin color except for white is a pretty good indicator of culture. Racial comedy is fairly large industry that only succeeds because it does a decent job of poking fun at behaviors that correlate with race.

"God only knows what you meant by 'accent.' Care to clarify?"

If someone speaks the Queen's English, you'll assign different probabilities to behaviors than if they spoke inner-city English.

I think race is useful in addition to the other indicators, but neither of us have any data on this, so I suppose we'll have to agree to disagree.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Friday March 05, 2010 @09:49PM (#1171047)
You continue to shift terms, so it makes it more difficult to pin you down.

My math is pretty solid - socio-economic classes are defined by values in intervals. So guessing the average income for each race would be guessing what interval? It would be guessing middle class for each race! Remember, you stated the proposition that, 'race is a good class indicator' - thus, we don't care about variance in the interval called middle class...

That is why I explicitly removed it from my analysis - if the only information(class-related) you get from a person's skin color is that they are middle-class, then you have effectively received no information. Certainly you can't be suggesting that those in the middle-class are more likely to commit crimes - can you be?

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by natrius on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:05PM (#1171066)
First of all, socioeconomic classes are artificial constructs. There's no reason to believe that there are large discontinuities in the probabilities of certain behaviors as income increases, though that is likely the case around poverty level.

From the census document you linked to, here are average household incomes by race:

Asian: $86,185

White, non-Hispanic: $74,102

Hispanic: $51,572

Black: $46,533

If you don't think there are substantial differences there, then we're not going to agree on anything.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:44PM (#1171158)
[Edit: Moved up a node to reflect the actual reply]

1. Socio-econonic classes are artificial constructs - so what? The point is that race is demonstrably unable to map the set of 'people' to the set of 'classes.'

2. If you are not able to accurately quote the figures from the pdf I linked to prior, then what is the likelyhood you even read it?

The ACTUAL median incomes can be found on pages 6-7:

Asian: $65,637

White, non-Hispanic: $55,530

Average: $50,000

Black: $34,218

The differences fall in the interval known as middle-class as I said before - so for the purposes of this discussion, they are not substantial.

[deleted]
Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by natrius on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:23PM (#1171143)
Settle down. I got the mean incomes from the table on pages 29-34, which a CTRL-F would've shown you. I chose the mean incomes because we were discussing how far off you'd be if you guessed a random person's income. Mean incomes would be the most accurate in that case. Median incomes are a perfectly fine metric as well.

The "set of classes" means nothing. If you're trying to predict someone's behavior, distinguishing someone who makes $59,999 from someone who makes $60,000 makes no sense. If it helps, pretend I said "socioeconomic status" every time I said "class". They're interchangeable to me, though the latter indeed implies discrete groups.

With that said, if you think living on $55,530 is anything like living on $34,218, you're just wrong. How can multiplying one's income by 1.6 not have a massive effect on their life?

That's ignoring the decreasing marginal utility of a dollar as incomes rise. The poverty threshold for a family of four is $22,025. Black households have a "surplus" income of $12,193. White households have a surplus income of $33,505. The average white family will find itself in a situation where theft is attractive far less often than the average black family.

"Not substantial"? Consider my mind boggled.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Saturday March 06, 2010 @12:21AM (#1171180)
[Edit: spelling mistakes]

Based on your response, you do not even understand the terms I've been using.

'Set of classes,' means everything per this discussion - as the discussion has been premised on the statement you made (that skin color is an indicator of class).

So when you say things like...:

"If you're trying to predict someone's behavior, distinguishing someone who makes $59,999 from someone who makes $60,000 makes no sense."

..You suggest that you either do not understand my argument, or, you do not understand what has been meant by the word "class" in this discussion.

So I'll say it again; Classes are defined by an interval on the set of natural numbers. This isn't a discussion about guessing incomes with any greater precision than those provided to us by said classes.

The data provided to us by the census bureau document is the average. Note that the "households" in the census include BOTH family and non-family households.

So, when you say things like...:

"The poverty threshold for a family of four is $22,025. Black households have a "surplus" income of $12,193. White households have a surplus income of $33,505."

...You hint that you didn't quite understand that the average provided was calculated including single-households as well as non-single households with kids. So your whole reply is a bit of a straw-man...

...But it isn't even really a good one. We are talking about race as a predictor so let us control for income and work backwards. Imagine two families, one black, the other white, both living with an income of $34,218, both with four children. Is it then your contention that the Black family is still more likely to produce a thief?

If so, I do consider your mind boggled.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by natrius on Saturday March 06, 2010 @01:10AM (#1171212)
I have said several times that I'm not talking about discrete classes, yet you insist on arguing that point. I do not think that race can predict whether someone is lower, middle or upper class. I do think that race can predict income. I don't understand why you continue to tell me what I meant by class when I have told you what I actually meant three times.

I understand the data completely. The family of four example was an illustration of the marginal utility of income. The point is that not only are $55,530 and $34,218 quite different numerically, but they're also vastly different in terms of the luxuries a household can afford.

You've spent so much time arguing semantics that you haven't even tried to disprove my assertion that households earning $55,530 and $34,218 will likely have different behaviors. If my assertion is true, then race is a valuable predictor of behavior.

Controlling for income makes no sense, as my claim was about outward predictors of behavior. No, I don't think black families and white families with the same incomes will have significant differences in criminality. I think that data does actually show that blacks commit more crime than whites even when you control for income, but I don't think the difference is big enough for it to be a valuable predictor of behavior.

Good night.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Saturday March 06, 2010 @02:08AM (#1171247)
[Edit: 'its' changed to 'opposite' for clarity, 'there' to 'their']

1. "I have said several times that I'm not talking about discrete classes, yet you insist on arguing that point."

Regardless of whether or not you meant to be "talking about discrete classes," you were. Socio-economic classes ARE discrete classes. So if you are talking about some other type of class, it is a mistake of comprehension on your behalf.

2. "I do not think that race can predict whether someone is lower, middle or upper class."

An explicit contradiction. I'll quote you directly:

"In America, skin color is a good predictor of class."

So which is it? Is race a good "predictor" of class or is it not?

3. "I do think that race can predict income."

This is the same thing as predicting class. Income is both necessary and sufficient for determining class, so if you could predict income by race, you could predict class by race. But you cannot do this (remember that guessing 'middle class' over and over is not allowed as it isn't information providing.).

4. "...you haven't even tried to disprove my assertion that households earning $55,530 and $34,218 will likely have different behaviors."

Ummm...that's because the opposite is taken for granted in the model of class. The middle class interval is traditionally considered to be from 30K to 75K - the class intervals are chosen precisely because the buying power in each strata is considered to be effectively equivalent. Again, if you don't understand this, then you do not understand the nature of classes - it just is what it is.

5. " If my assertion is true, then race is a valuable predictor of behavior."

No. Even if your assertion is true, all it shows is that income is a predictor of class. Well, duh - classes are defined by incomes. Behavior has no relation to any of these variables - that is, bad behaviors are distributed in equal proportions across the class strata. Income may predict risk-levels associated with bad-behaviors, but not necessarily their frequency.

6. "No, I don't think black families and white families with the same incomes will have significant differences in criminality."

Exactly. So then, there is no predictive ability that race has for any arbitrary class strata. It immediately follows then, that race has no predictive ability in terms of class. QED.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Saturday March 06, 2010 @10:20AM (#1171614)
Though it is tangential at best to this discussion, let me say that I find it absolutely hilarious that in this thread and the one above it, I have written provably true statements and have been down-modded, whereas the people who I have been responding to have written provably false statements (outright contradictions!) and have been up-modded.

If the point-system rewards shallow group-think, and punishes truth - 'What is the point of it?', I must ask.

Heck, this has now become my new standard for judging content quality - let me see how many provably true, on-topic things one says in a thread, so that their score drops below unity.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by natrius on Saturday March 06, 2010 @12:58PM (#1171847)
I think you were downmodded because you were consistently arguing against points I explicitly told you I wasn't making. You are not some sort of martyr for truth.

You also tried to use the model of class to prove that people with vastly different incomes behave the same. You cannot prove with a model without proving that the model is accurate. The model you're using is wrong.

As I said before, I was never trying to appeal to the model of class anywhere in this discussion. I asked you to pretend I said socioeconomic status instead so we could stop arguing points I never made, but you wouldn't do me that favor.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by Mz on Friday March 05, 2010 @08:21PM (#1170960)
Skin color isn't any more an indicator of class than shoe size or fingernail length.

Actually, long fingernails on a woman are typically used to signal "I don't do manual labor" and is very much intended as a class indicator. It's part of the appeal of long nails. As I understand it, there is lots of historical precedent across a number of cultures for this.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Friday March 05, 2010 @08:56PM (#1170998)
Even if I were to allow that the discussion be gender-biased, I'm afraid this wouldn't be accurate...

The very poor tend to have poor grooming habits, both in frequency and quality. As such, access to nail clippers is extremely limited...

Further, the nature of living in extreme poverty forbids the biting of one's nails; you would be shocked at the amount of dirt and grime that gathers there after just a few days without access to a bathroom or running water.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by Mz on Friday March 05, 2010 @09:06PM (#1171006)
I am aware that it is not entirely gender-based. However, a quick google turns up this:

http://www.efingernails.com/fingernails-history/

Fingernails became shorter and the colours less intense during the 1980's when women became more interested in their work.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/style/feed/a41653-1999d...

Thorsten Veblen wrote in his classic "The Theory of the Leisure Class" (1899). "It not only shows that the wearer is able to consume a relatively large value, but it argues at the same time that he consumes without producing." Like the constrictive corset of Veblen's time, long nails today signal which women are too rich and too feminine (wouldn't want the little darling to break a nail) to perform manual labor.

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by najirama on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:10PM (#1171074)
Both of those links engender the proposition that fingernail length is indeed NOT a good indicator of class.

The class status of women as a whole rose significantly in the 80's as women's pay relative to men's rose from 1980 to 1990 (from 60.2% to 71.6%):

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/03/nyregion/03women.html?ex=1...

Re:The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupi... by Mz on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:29PM (#1171090)
It is not as simple as that. Women going to work in large numbers means they stopped being part of a "leisure class". A non-working wife is a status symbol. It means the man makes enough that his wife doesn't need to work. Nothing is sweepingly one thing or the other. But, in general, long fingernails have historically been a status symbol/class indicator -- long, clean, well-groomed and often decorated (painted, treated with henna, etc), not long and filthy.

Long fingernails are also a fairly strong "sex" symbol. One prostitute wrote in her biography that she could work at the mall by wearing very high heels and long, red fingernails. I will also add that long nails are an indicator of health (trying not to turn every discussion towards my medical condition, but my genetic disorder is how I know this one so well) -- and that tends to be linked to class in that wealthier classes tend to be better fed.