Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by pavel_lishin on Friday March 05, 2010 @02:35PM
(#1170255)
My stepfather told me to never preface a counter-argument with "yeah, but". He told me that other people hear it as "I didn't listen to what you said, but am talking anyway."
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by TravisLS on Friday March 05, 2010 @03:05PM
(#1170340)
Probably the most useful piece of advice I've ever heard regarding this kind of discourse: A mediator friend of mine once told me to always attempt to briefly recap the other person's point before beginning a counter-argument. That way they know you heard what they said, and they have the opportunity to correct any inaccuracies before you get going.
Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by mcantor on Friday March 05, 2010 @05:03PM
(#1170612)
This simple exercise is more than just a trapping of mutualistic discourse. It actually forces you to think about their point, and leads to a greater understanding of what they are trying to say... which, in turn, allows you to waste less time by explaining a counterpoint to an argument that they didn't make.
I try to make myself do this even when I'm not arguing with someone. If a task comes to me from my boss, I will do my best to rephrase it in my own words (not verbatim, unless it's something really simple) to make sure we're on the same page.
Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by count on Saturday March 06, 2010 @08:35AM
(#1171513)
People who do this in every conversation annoy the everliving hell out of me.
In a philosophical or rhetorical debate, it's an excellent strategy, but in day to day office conversations, ugh.
Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by cheald on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:35AM
(#1171455)
I think the nerd equivalent of this is "Well, actually...". Whenever I hear that, I kind of just mentally sigh and roll my eyes, and I say that as someone who identifies as a nerd with verbal communication issues.
Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by jrockway on Friday March 05, 2010 @06:28PM
(#1170779)
He told me that other people hear it as "I didn't listen to what you said, but am talking anyway."
Don't worry, even if you don't say "yeah, but", I still think that.
Re:If Nerds Can Learn Linux, Why Can't They Learn Not To Int...
by pieceofpeace on Saturday March 06, 2010 @12:40AM
(#1171197)
But why would you assume that?