Re:Winograd Schemas
by panic on Sunday May 15, 2016 @08:48PM
(#11703565)
Winograd schemas depend on world knowledge. The phrases "in the possession of" and "in possession of" mean different things apart from any particular knowledge about police or criminals.
Re:Winograd Schemas
by rvense on Sunday May 15, 2016 @09:03PM
(#11703617)
Dennis Skinner, member of the British House of Commons, once said in a speech that "half the Tories opposite are crooks!". When asked to withdraw the statement, he said "OK, half the Tories opposite aren't crooks."
So in the presence of 'half', even 'not' can be unpredictable...
Re:Winograd Schemas
by gfaure on Sunday May 15, 2016 @10:17PM
(#11703840)
Amusing... but this isn't the same kind of ambiguity as he intentionally made the negation have the wrong scope. The expected negation would be "It is not the case that half the Tories opposite are crooks".
Re:Winograd Schemas
by zeckalpha on Monday May 16, 2016 @11:07PM
(#11711145)
That's the denotation vs. connotation split. To me, the denotation is different but it does not resolve the scoping of "they", rather the connotation is what resolves the scope.
Re:Winograd Schemas
by dnautics on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:41PM
(#11703320)
The classical Winograd schema as a Turing test is effectively the voight-kampff test: one could imagine that the council advocated violence, and surreptitiously sought to create say a false flag, but our mirror system and sense of morality make that interpretation less palatable.
Re:Winograd Schemas
by whitten on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:55PM
(#11703178)
There is a programming project in Artificial Intelligence named Shrdlite that is a course given at the University of Gothenburg and Chalmers University of Technology.
The course also includes the nearley parser to provide a blocksworld, similar to Terry's original work.
For more information, see the course webpages:
"The criminals were in the possession of the police."
"The criminals were in possession of the police."
One of the odder quirks of English.
So in the presence of 'half', even 'not' can be unpredictable...
http://ChalmersGU-AI-course.github.io/