News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by bnegreve on Sunday May 15, 2016 @02:51AM (#11699810)
Interesting point, but to be fair China is not the only one to find ways to implement protectionism. The F35 program or even Nasa contracting SpaceX could be seen as examples of the US implementing some level of protectionism.
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by argonaut on Sunday May 15, 2016 @03:35AM (#11699919)
Every nation has protectionism. Every single one. What's important is the degree of protectionism. So pointing out examples of a nation engaging in protectionism contributes little to the discussion unless you compare it to other nations.
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by sangnoir on Sunday May 15, 2016 @04:09AM (#11700004)
> What's important is the degree of protectionism

The US complaining about China's protectionism is hypocritical. Let's talk about America's farm subsidies. How is that not competing unfairly? It leads to American agricultural produce being dumped on foreign markets at subsidized prices, destroying entire countries' agricultural base. What would you say is the degree of protectionism here?

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by golergka on Sunday May 15, 2016 @05:58AM (#11700218)
Farm subsidies is not only about business, it's about national security: you subside food industry so that when you suddenly find yourself in the big war with trade routes cut, your population doesn't starve.

I'm not saying that these subsidies are necessary; I'm just saying that they should be analyzed with a different framework.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by gbog on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:39AM (#11700336)
That's true but even more so when applied to the computer network. Nowadays, in case of a war, closing emails or zombying all Windows pcs could do more harm than food supplies.
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by golergka on Sunday May 15, 2016 @08:01AM (#11700595)
And that's why for countries who aren't US closest allies it makes total sense to base military infrastructure on open-source operating systems and software (because let's be honest, Russian or Chinese military most likely won't be able to produce their own modern OS of comparable quality from scratch).

However, software and hardware on one hard, and internet on another, aren't the same thing: I don't see how one can seriously make the same argument in favor of great chinese firewall. It's only effective against general population, and doesn't seriously negate any cyber-threats, as far as I understand.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by gbog on Sunday May 15, 2016 @09:32AM (#11700828)
Why only military infrastructure? Image a war between, say the USA and Russia, and imagine that the USA manages to shut down or cripple all Windows machines in Russia, this will probably put the enemy on the kneels, even more than weeks of airstrikes. And it may also be better PR as it do not directly "kill" anyone. I have always thought that Microsoft holding 95% of PCs in the world is extremely dangerous, and can't get why American, with their admirable foundness of personal freedom and security, do not decide to put a stop to this anomaly. (Imagine, if 95% of world's oil was provided by one company?)
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by golergka on Sunday May 15, 2016 @10:00AM (#11700917)
Because unlike oil, computers running on different OS create difficulties for users and developers. Apart from the point of national security, I think it's reasonable to assume that in an alternative world, where 20 operating systems competed on desktop market with more-or-less equal market shares, everybody would suffer from neverending compatibility problems, we would have worse applications, a lot of businesses would never succeed and a lot less value would be created in IT industry overall.

Hell, we don't even have to imagine — remember testing JS on every browser around 2007?

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by gbog on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:55PM (#11703370)
20 different operating systems would have shown the necessity of a common open protocol for the filesystem being it, and would have given much more space to creativity on the computer.
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by wrong_variable on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:24AM (#11700296)
Not really,

Being self sufficient for war and producing excess agriculture product and dumping it on foreign markets are two completely different things.

And two can play at that game - china can make the same 'national security' nonsense argument about information espionage when it comes to the internet.

And in the modern world - the internet is more useful then food for a nation state - america can lose 30 million people and still win a total war as long as its nukes are functional.

Its all about protectionism.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by argonaut on Sunday May 15, 2016 @04:11AM (#11700007)
I'll just repeat my extremely short comment:

> pointing out examples of a nation engaging in protectionism contributes little to the discussion unless you compare it to other nations.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by sangnoir on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:22AM (#11700289)
I thought the implicit comparison to any country was obvious and well known - maybe not to Americans[1]. Can you think of any country that practices protectionism on agriculture at the same level as the US?

1. I would have thought post-"corn-syrup-gate" more Americans would at least know corn is heavily subsidized.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by argonaut on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:34AM (#11700519)
To make a good point, you also need to show that China doesn't have agricultural subsidies.

5 seconds of Google searching reveals a long lists of results:

https://www.google.com/#q=chinese+agricultural+subsidies

http://www.economist.com/news/china/21651272-others-cut-farm...

Agricultural subsidies are really not going to support your point. Most countries have heavy agricultural subsidies.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by TeMPOraL on Sunday May 15, 2016 @04:52AM (#11700083)
It's being implicitly compared to China, and well, to everyone else.
Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by bnegreve on Sunday May 15, 2016 @03:54AM (#11699966)
Every nation has protectionism.

Yes, that's my point. Not every one agrees with this and GGP's comment doesn't mention this fact.

So pointing out examples [..] contributes little to the discussion.

It adds examples of US protectionism so you can compare them with the ones from China that were mentioned before. Hopefully, this contributes to a more objective point of view. Why do I need to justify this?

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by argonaut on Sunday May 15, 2016 @04:12AM (#11700013)
Because China's space program and defense industry are protected as well. So if we're really going to try to decide whether China or the US are more protectionist than the other, in that comparison the examples cancel each other out. All you've done is add examples to both sides of the balance beam.

And we're still left with examples of Chinese internet industry protectionism.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by bayesian_horse on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:33AM (#11700323)
SpaceX has better and cheaper rockets. I don't think they are exceptionally profiting from a "buy American" effect.

For the F-35 program, it contains a lot of technology which can't be found anywhere else in the world, and much of that technology was funded by the US government. For all the ridicule the project got, the corresponding projects in Russia and China are even worse off... If anything, the F-35 program is overpriced because there are no reasonable adversaries.

Re:Beijing is Silicon Valley's only true competitor by GunboatDiplomat on Sunday May 15, 2016 @08:23AM (#11700642)
They could be, but I'd say that wanting to produce your own fighters (especially for a large military like ours) is reasonable. We're not complaining that the Chinese don't want to buy the F-35.

Isn't SpaceX substantially cheaper than any other alternative at this point?