News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by andreygrehov on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:08AM (#11699384)
A friend of mine (she is a microbiologist, let's call her Lucy) was diagnosed with Uterine cancer. Oncologist told her they have to remove her womb, otherwise she'll die in a couple weeks. She decided to avoid "traditional treatment". Instead, she shared her issue with various professors from the university she is working at. One of the professors (another friend of mine) advised her to go to the Republic of Peru. He gave her contacts of his friend who's already been there and suggested to talk to him first. Lucy got in touch with this guy, he convinced her to go and in a week or so she was already in Peru.

In Peru, Lucy met some sort of a shaman. He wrote down her a list of things she must eat and things to avoid. This list also contained some herb, that she had to eat during the 2-3 months she was there.

After a few months, she got back home. 6 months after - no cancer. Year after this all happened she was dancing at my sister's wedding, healthy and happy.

Now as for the Peru guy and the friend of my friend who been there :) He had a brother. They both got cancer. One of the brothers decided to go with traditional treatment (radiation and all that). The other one went to Peru.

Long story short: the one who picked traditional methods died many years ago. The other one (who convinced Lucy to go) - completely recovered.

As far as I know, overall treatment was less than $5,000. If I'm not wrong, this was including rent + air flight.

I must add, that Lucy lost 45 pounds within a year. During my sister's wedding, she was only eating some oceanic fish and rice.

Edit:

This is just a short story from people I know in person. All of them are scientists working at university, doing researches on molecular genetics & microbiology.

I'm not even sure the guy in Peru was a shaman. That's just how I called him here. I just don't believe he was a real doctor. The gist of the whole treatment was fasting, not a herb.

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:34AM (#11699448)
This is a scam, pure and simple. People die from this shit needlessly all the time. Doesn't uterine cancer have a very high survival rate with proper treatment? But no, this "microbiologist" treks off to the Peruvian jungle to spend a measly $5k for a magical herb that cures cancer! Doctors hate this one weird trick!

If you or someone you know has cancer, go see an oncologist, not a freaking shaman.

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by andreygrehov on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:35AM (#11699450)
> Oncologist told her they have to remove her womb, otherwise she'll die in a couple weeks.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:42AM (#11699467)
Sorry, I've heard all this before. My family is packed with people who "know someone" who amazed all the doctors by curing their cancers with weird diets, herbs, and prayers. I don't buy any of it. Unless you have some data, it's basically worthless noise.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by galuggus on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:42AM (#11699466)
One of the worst things about cancer is hearing stories like this all the time. It's really unhelpful and very draining to have your body undergo hell and your mind besieged by well=intentioned idiots telling you to expel toxins/ pray the cancer away/ stop eating this.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by nommm-nommm on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:40AM (#11700342)
Having any chronic illness makes you hear this nonsense too, tons of unsolicited and unwanted "advice."
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by andreygrehov on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:44AM (#11699469)
Agree. Maybe this is all a coincidence they both survived and the other guy passed away. Have no idea. Shared what I know. Nothing less, nothing more.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:49AM (#11699480)
You don't really know anything of value about this though. Are you an oncologist? Did you see her scans and test results? Have you been to her follow ups? Talked with her doctors? Do you even know the name of this magical herb that cures cancer but has somehow eluded the attention of thousands of researchers desperate to save hundreds of millions of suffering people, including their own loved ones?
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by andreygrehov on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:59AM (#11699508)
Ryan, there is no magical herb. The gist of treatment was fasting. I have no idea what kind of diet it was. Do you want to know more? I can ask her details and the other guy who survived by sticking to the same diet.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @01:10AM (#11699539)
I want to know whether they're dedicating their lives to winning a Nobel prize and saving billions of lives with this magical cure. If not, why not? They had fatal cancers cured in just a few months with no treatment, and then just went back to work and forgot about it?

Also, if the essence is fasting, why did they need to go see a shaman in Peru?

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by reddytowns on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:45AM (#11700357)
The problem is that medical science today isn't equipped to prove/disprove this kind of medicine. All that would happen if they could convince anyone to even believe the story, which I highly doubt, is one study would be conducted.

The scientists would ignore all the diagnosis and individual examination the shaman did, and the study would probably have the participants take a specific amount of a single specific herb on a single specific schedule. Basically, they'd take all the complexities of the alternative medical system and tried to distill it down to a one-size-fits-all regimen.

Then, after it undoubtedly showed no effect, they'd proclaim the shaman is a fraud and that nothing he does really works.

I mean, really, are you going to sit there and tell me that its more logical that all the alternative medical systems developed over thousands of years are bullshit, than the possibility that modern medicine has gaps covered by these other medical systems, that can't/won't be filled using the scientific method, wrapped and perverted as it is by the hubris and single-minded culture of the doctors and scientists using it?

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @08:45AM (#11700699)
So the only kind of "science" that could prove this works is to layer on so many confounding effects and other variables that it'd be impossible to tell what, if anything, is happening.

Gee, I wonder why rational people are skeptical of that.

And to answer your question, no, I do not believe that alternative health systems "developed" over thousands of years work. If they work, then they're medicine. We only use the term alternative health to define things that are too magical to have their effects show up when studied using the scientific method. And barring the ability to collect some reliable data on their efficacy, then yes, they're bullshit by default. What other reliable framework for evaluating them could I possibly have?

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by carapace on Sunday May 15, 2016 @01:23PM (#11701773)
We have to come up with something rigorous to deal with these sorts of things. Whether you call it "science" or not we still have to come to grips with "weird shit".

I know a guy. He's a healer. He can do things that Western science has absolutely no idea about. In point of fact several people who were diagnosed with cancer have worked with him and afterwards were no longer diagnosed with cancer.

This is factual.

Yet good luck getting people in general to take this seriously. No one wants to hear it. My mom's neighbour had breast cancer, she beat it with conventional medicine, more power to her. But she refused even to think about anything outside of the established system. For her it worked.

Personally, I'm very frustrated. I come from a strongly scientific background, so when I meet a person who can fucking cure fucking cancer I would really like to see the scientific establishment take that seriously.

But whatever. I can take some consolation that at least my family and I don't have to worry about cancer, even if I can do nothing to change the zeitgeist of society.

For those of you wondering why this guy wouldn't try to spread the word, well, first of all he does! He talks to anyone he meets and is not shy about it at all. The limiting factor is the people who don't want to hear about crazy shit.

(P.S. If you have cancer and want to talk to my healer friend I can put you in touch. He's in Europe now and kind of retired, and I haven't spoken to him in a year or so, but if you truly need help and feel that this guy is "the one" you can contact me and I'll see about putting you in touch.)

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @02:20PM (#11702040)
This is factual.

Well, no, it's not. From my perspective, this is yet another random anecdote from the Internet. It's no different to me than someone saying they can turn base metals into gold, hear the voice of God directly, or travel to alternate dimensions.

And even from YOUR perspective, you have no idea what's fact and what's not. Apparently this healer is so powerful that your family need not worry about cancer. But I suspect you have little hard evidence of any actual healing, no proposed mechanisms that make any sense, and no ability to reproduce any of this.

The amazing thing about the scientific method is that it gives us a framework to separate claims from reality. If you have a better framework then please share it. But there seems to be little value to a framework built on "I know a guy, trust me." We had that for thousands of years. Health care under such a framework was pretty rough.

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by reddytowns on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:40PM (#11703126)
I'm not arguing that the scientific method is invalid. Just that it's applied in a way today that is typically unable to prove or disprove if alternative medicine works or not.

The shaman might tell you, I look into their eyes and if I see a slight yellowness I know X. Then I measure their pulse and that tells me Y. So based on that I prescribe medicine A at dose B.

Now if someone designed a study that first separated people into a category where both X and Y are true, and then gave only those people the medicine the shaman recommended, you'd have a real test. But this isn't done.

Humanity has produced great things before the scientific method existed, agriculture, smelting, sea travel, etc., including the scientific method, itself! How can you reconcile this fact with your proclamation that anything related to medicine, a body of knowledge produced from the same people at the same period of time is all bullshit?

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by carapace on Sunday May 15, 2016 @01:03PM (#11701661)
Exactly. We need a new kind of science that works for living systems.

"When you kick a stone the energy for its resulting movement comes from your foot. When you kick a dog..."

Complex living systems with scads of "free" energy are not susceptible to the same formal method that revealed and is still revealing Physics.

We need a new science.

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @02:11PM (#11702002)
I can't tell if this is satire. I really hope so.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by atrust on Sunday May 15, 2016 @02:54PM (#11702193)
It's obvious that the author doesn't know all the details and you keep asking all of these questions over and over again, making yourself look like a troll.

I have a feeling that the _magical_ Peruvian cure is based on eating blister beetles, which is a popular treatment in Chinese medicine. Apparently, chemicals these bugs make could be beneficial in treating certain kinds of cancer. There are a few researches going on on that front.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24733674

http://www.academia.edu/1279793/Antitumor_Activity_of_Mylabr...

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by andreygrehov on Sunday May 15, 2016 @01:34AM (#11699591)
That's a good question. I moved to another city and had no chance (and interest) to know what they were doing after the recovery. I'll try to figure it out. You made me curious.

I see you want more data, but, unfortunately, I cannot provide you with any other details. I don't like your tone and would love to close this thread. Thank you.

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @01:48AM (#11699640)
I just don't understand. You clearly believe that their method cured their cancer. But you lost interest From there? I obviously don't believe their method works, but if I did, I wouldn't just shuffle off to do something else. I just don't understand how you, and these cured scientists could all just shrug at this incredibly miraculous and basically free cure of a horrible disease that will kill tens of millions of people this year alone.
Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by ryanwaggoner on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:52AM (#11699488)
Doesn't it strike you as incredibly shady or selfish that these scientists who had their cancer cured haven't bothered to tell the world about it?

Or if they're currently researching it to help others not die from cancers that can be easily cured, please point us to their work.

Re:An Old Idea, Revived: Starve Cancer to Death by tremon on Sunday May 15, 2016 @08:06AM (#11700605)
Doesn't it strike you as incredibly shady or selfish that these scientists who had their cancer cured haven't bothered to tell the world about it?

It doesn't, actually. Getting diagnosed with cancer and then surviving it is still a terrible ordeal. Publishing their single story would do nothing to change the course of medical science, but it would open them up to abuse from skeptics all over the world.

I'm sure that even if I survived cancer (through whatever means), I would still not have the courage to allow myself to be flagellated by a horde of entitled zealots.