News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by pjc50 on Saturday May 14, 2016 @08:39AM (#11695836)
If it's got a password, it's not really public wifi. Isn't it usually complementary wifi for patrons of a particular business?
Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by jackvalentine on Saturday May 14, 2016 @08:46AM (#11695854)
I think he might be referring to "public" but not public wifi, like coffee shops etc.

I've long thought that if your business is using public unlicensed spectrum then you should be required to let the public in.

A very large national phone carrier in my country is blanketing the cities with wifi reserved for their customers - using a public resource and clogging up the unlicensed spectrum for private gain. They've already bought a lot of spectrum licenses, but clearly using public spectrum is a cost-effective way to add capacity.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by codecamper on Saturday May 14, 2016 @08:54AM (#11695879)
Ugh.. and it is so hard to actually get on those wifi networks -- at least as a traveller. They'll give it free to mobile customers, who never bother to use it.

Yes, I was referring to cafe / resto wifi. If one opens it, then people take advantage, but if everyone opens theirs, then nobody bothers. Only some really cheapskate neighbors who most probably don't consume all that much of it anyways.

everybody has a smartphone now, most don't bother asking for the wifi password. If you ask for it, then often the next problem is the router doesn't work because nobody has used it in so long.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by jjawssd on Saturday May 14, 2016 @10:51AM (#11696340)
Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by mseebach on Saturday May 14, 2016 @09:29AM (#11696011)
Large scale public wifi generally doesn't have passwords, that clearly doesn't scale, they have fancy enterprise auth things or captive portals. Shared password only works for small places like coffee shops.

Anecdotes: 1: on London Underground, my phone authenticates using the SIM somehow (it still shows a captive portal screen, just with an ad, yay). 2: in the Turkish lounge in Istanbul airport, the shared password was clearly a marketing channel, InvestInTK2016 or some such. It struck me as pretty clever.

> if your business is using public unlicensed spectrum then you should be required to let the public in

"Unlicensed" isn't really "unlicensed", as much as specifically licensed for anyone to do with as they please. But to take your idea just one step further, once you've opened up all wifi for the general publics consumption (what a renaissance for wired networking!), would people using it be allowed to use it for private gain? Why is it wrong to use unlicensed spectrum for private gain, but not to use a service provided over the same spectrum for private gain? Also, as a business, under this doctrine, are you allowed to enable wifi access to a closed non-internet LAN, with only locked-down non-public servers on it?

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by simoncion on Saturday May 14, 2016 @06:59PM (#11698447)
> "Unlicensed" isn't really "unlicensed", as much as specifically licensed for anyone to do with as they please.

One does not need a license to operate a radio in the WiFi bands, so that spectrum is unlicensed. However, it is not unregulated. :)

> Anecdotes: 1: on London Underground, my phone authenticates using the SIM somehow...

That might be EAP-SIM [0].

EAP (and WPA2-EAP) is really cool. I really wish that MSFT would configure their WiFi supplicants to not care if the key of the PEAP or TTLS server they're talking to is signed by an unknown CA. This would let coffee shop owners deploy encrypted but password-less WiFi and shut down a whole class of attacks. [1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensible_Authentication_Prot...

[1] Seriously, MSFT obviously designed their WPA2-EAP GUIs only for use in an enterprise environment. There's no way for a Windows user to connect to a WPA2-EAP network that uses PEAP or TTLS with a cert from an unknown CA by just clicking on the network in the network browser and punching in some credentials. You must manually configure the network, then uncheck a checkbox buried beneath a couple of menus. What's more, the error you get if you don't do this is entirely unhelpful. :/ In contrast, Apple's GUI for this is actually useful: "This cert is unknown. You want to trust it for this WiFi network?". Say yes and off you go!

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by jackvalentine on Saturday May 14, 2016 @10:46AM (#11696315)
> But to take your idea just one step further, once you've opened up all wifi for the general publics consumption (what a renaissance for wired networking!)

I think this requires clarification - I don't mean no business should ever use wifi. I mean businesses like telephone companies shouldn't be using to augment their networks. Obviously offices and the like need secure wireless networking that normal hardware can connect to.

> Why is it wrong to use unlicensed spectrum for private gain

Maybe with my above correction this isn't needed, but in cities the 2.4ghz channel is loaded to death and in a few years the 5ghz channel will be the same. All I'm objecting to are these closed commercial networks from people who should be paying for the spectrum bunging up the open one the rest of us use. My city is soaked with a wifi network that is closed to everyone except the customers of a telco. If your primary business is providing network connectivity, perhaps you should pay for the finite resource you use.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by mseebach on Saturday May 14, 2016 @11:34AM (#11696544)
So you're speaking of a specific problem in a specific place - this is kind of hard to know when it was phrased as a general principle.

Also, it's hard to discuss the issue when there are no details about the specific issue available.

But two points: First, where I am, 2.4Ghz is perfectly swamped with normal residential access points. It seems unlikely that this telco in your city did much more than move up the point where the spectrum is swamped, rather than causing it directly (also, if their use is affecting everyone else, they themselves are affected, too, rendering their investment pretty pointless, which leads me to wonder just how bad the situation actually is). Second, if you do want to regulate, in a rule-of-law-compatible way, well, it's going to be hard to distinguish a Starbucks access point operated for the benefit of customers of Starbucks from a telco access point operated for the benefit of customers of that telco. (If you want to use spectrum ownership as the metric, consider that many telcos cover both spectrum-owning mobile and commercial and residential broadband (ie wifi-providing) subsidiaries). To further muddy the waters, the telco is very likely to be selling access to their wifi network to non-subscribers.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by hueving on Saturday May 14, 2016 @11:52AM (#11696636)
>it's going to be hard to distinguish a Starbucks access point operated for the benefit of customers of Starbucks from a telco access point operated for the benefit of customers of that telco

Not really. Usually there is an actual Starbucks where there is Starbucks WiFi and it doesn't extend much beyond the coffee shop. In this case and the case of Comcast in the US, the company is using other people's property for broadcasting wireless.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by jackvalentine on Saturday May 14, 2016 @09:27PM (#11698903)
No I am speaking of a general principle and using an example.

I don't particularly want to get out the spectrum analysis gear and argue with your points in a ground war. I think for discussing a general idea it's a distraction.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by mseebach on Saturday May 14, 2016 @09:05AM (#11695928)
Public doesn't mean free to everybody, it means available to everybody. A public house (as opposed to a private club), aka a pub, is not a place you can hang out whenever, they have hours (they are not "public" at night) and you're supposed to buy stuff when you're in there.

There's nothing about password protected wifi that makes it inherently non-public.

Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by Spivak on Saturday May 14, 2016 @10:57AM (#11696374)
I think he means when certain Telcoms blanket entire cities with Wi-Fi in the unlicensed spectrum which at scale makes everyone else's connection worse. I have no problem with blanketing cities with internet access but I think commercial wireless should have their own frequency -- which would actually be good for them since they would be mostly alone in the space and could get a frequency which is better suited to large scale coverage.
Re:Germany plans to remove owner liability for piracy on ope... by dogma1138 on Saturday May 14, 2016 @11:54AM (#11696650)
I live in London which has allot of telco wifi everywhere and I haven't seen any adverse impact on my signal.

Wifi is saturated regardless of it being metro or not, relatively speaking the strongest signals by far will come from your neighbours not the telcos.