News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by espadrine on Saturday May 14, 2016 @06:54AM (#11695530)
Has there been updates on the legal situation since http://blog.halon.org.uk/2016/01/on-zfs-in-debian/?

I am obviously glad that this happened, but afraid of an Oraclocalypse.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by seba_dos1 on Saturday May 14, 2016 @07:40AM (#11695657)
It's just that the thing described in this article finally happened: "TLDR: It’s going in contrib, as a source only dkms module."
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by snuxoll on Saturday May 14, 2016 @02:06PM (#11697320)
> Oraclocalypse

The CDDL doesn't have any problems being linked into GPL'ed code, it is the GPL that has a problem accepting CDDL code.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by belorn on Saturday May 14, 2016 @04:04PM (#11697813)
If we could ignore the CDDL conditions, then the problems would go away. A license incompatibility happens when two licenses has each some conditions which are incompatible with each other, and the authors of software under those licenses do not give additional permissions.

The problem would go away if you convinced oracle to change the license or give explicit permission to link ZFS with the linux kernel under the GPL conditions.

Or:

Convinced the linux kernel team to change their license or give explicit permission to link the linux kernel with ZFS under the CDDL conditions.

Or you can blame "GPL", because it obviously was created after CDDL...

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by andreasvc on Saturday May 14, 2016 @05:34PM (#11698132)
> Or you can blame "GPL", because it obviously was created after CDDL...

It's the other way around.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by snuxoll on Saturday May 14, 2016 @06:45PM (#11698397)
Sarcasm was implied.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by SolarNet on Sunday May 15, 2016 @04:37AM (#11700049)
Wait, there is sarcasm on the internet? What's the markdown for that?
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by ZenoArrow on Sunday May 15, 2016 @05:56AM (#11700210)
> "What's the markdown for that?"

/s

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by SolarNet on Sunday May 15, 2016 @06:36AM (#11700329)
The sarcasm was that the great-great-grandparent didn't use it.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by ZenoArrow on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:57AM (#11700583)
It's not a requirement, you don't have to use it every time you employ sarcasm online, it just helps if it's likely to be misunderstood.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by legulere on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:26AM (#11700497)
> If we could ignore the CDDL conditions, then the problems would go away.

That's a strange way to say relicensing CDDL code under GPL

> A license incompatibility happens when two licenses has each some conditions which are incompatible with each other,

I think it's a bit of a far stretch to say that both licenses are to blame when one license has a so far reaching condition that other code needs to be relicensable under that license.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by belorn on Sunday May 15, 2016 @02:33PM (#11702099)
Any Covered Software that You distribute or otherwise make available in Executable form must also be made available in Source Code form and that Source Code form must be distributed only under the terms of this License. The Modifications that You create or to which You contribute are governed by the terms of this License.

Which license require that other code needs to be relicensable under its license? this license really means, this license. Modified code is required to be under, and I will repeat myself here, this license. If source code is not under this license, then it is infringing on this license condition and this license will no longer permit redistribution.

This license has a condition, and this license condition makes it incompatible with every other license that has an identical condition.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by Annatar on Sunday May 15, 2016 @05:30AM (#11700143)
Oracle has nothing whatsoever to do with this code: this is OpenZFS, out of the illumos' source tree.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by ZenoArrow on Sunday May 15, 2016 @05:53AM (#11700200)
If there's money to be made, Oracle will make defending ZFS their business, regardless of the source of the implementation. Look at what's happening over Java with the Oracle vs. Google court cases:

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/05/round-2-of-oracle...

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by Annatar on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:18AM (#11700474)
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by ZenoArrow on Sunday May 15, 2016 @08:06AM (#11700606)
Did you not read what I said? It doesn't matter whether it's a fork or not. If Oracle wins the current lawsuit over Java, it's arguable they could go after OpenZFS too as the lawsuit is based on whether the design of software (not the implementation, the design) can be owned by a company.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_America,_Inc._v._Goog....

"The appeals court reversed the district court on the central issue, holding that the "structure, sequence and organization" of an API was copyrightable."

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by Annatar on Sunday May 15, 2016 @03:46PM (#11702409)
Java and illumos are licensed under two completely different licenses, and neither illumos code base, nor OpenZFS are an application programming interface.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by gnufx on Sunday May 15, 2016 @03:34PM (#11702364)
If you're afraid of Oracle suing Debian for doing less than Oracle themselves do for profit (with linux+dtrace), you could get the distribution from zfsonlinux.org. Then the risk is transferred to .gov, who are also significant end users for enormous high-performance parallel filesystems. They have also been distributing binaries for RHEL-ish kernels for a while.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by thrownaway2424 on Saturday May 14, 2016 @03:18PM (#11697636)
+1 to this. I wouldn't touch ZFS or DTrace or anything else from Sun/Oracle with a 30-million-foot pole.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by kangar00 on Saturday May 14, 2016 @07:41AM (#11695662)
Oraclepocalypse? Aren't their lawyers busy with Google?: http://fortune.com/2016/05/13/google-oracle-java-email/

Here's another post about GPL violations related to combining ZFS and Linux: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2016/feb/25/zfs-and-linux/

Quote from that:

"Is The Analysis Different With Source-Only Distribution?

We cannot close discussion without considering one final unique aspect to this situation. CDDLv1 does allow for free redistribution of ZFS source code. We can also therefore consider the requirements when distributing Linux and ZFS in source code form only.

Pure distribution of source with no binaries is undeniably different. When distributing source code and no binaries, requirements in those sections of GPLv2 and CDDLv1 that cover modification and/or binary (or “Executable”, as CDDLv1 calls it) distribution do not activate. Therefore, the analysis is simpler, and we find no specific clause in either license that prohibits source-only redistribution of Linux and ZFS, even on the same distribution media.

Nevertheless, there may be arguments for contributory and/or indirect copyright infringement in many jurisdictions. We present no specific analysis ourselves on the efficacy of a contributory infringement claim regarding source-only distributions of ZFS and Linux. However, in our GPL litigation experience, we have noticed that judges are savvy at sniffing out attempts to circumvent legal requirements, and they are skeptical about attempts to exploit loopholes. Furthermore, we cannot predict Oracle's view — given its past willingness to enforce copyleft licenses, and Oracle's recent attempts to adjudicate the limits of copyright in Court. Downstream users should consider carefully before engaging in even source-only distribution.

We note that Debian's decision to place source-only ZFS in a relegated area of their archive called contrib, is an innovative solution. Debian fortunately had a long-standing policy that contrib was specifically designed for source code that, while licensed under an acceptable license for Debian's Free Software Guidelines, also has a default use that can cause licensing problems for downstream Debian users. Therefore, Debian communicates clearly to their users that this code is problematic by keeping it out of their main archive. Furthermore, Debian does not distribute any binary form of zfs.ko.

(Full disclosure: Conservancy has a services agreement with Debian in which Conservancy occasionally gives its opinions, in a non-legal capacity, to Debian on topics of Free Software licensing, and gave Debian advice on this matter under that agreement. Conservancy is not Debian's legal counsel.)"

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by espadrine on Saturday May 14, 2016 @07:47AM (#11695678)
> Aren't their lawyers busy with Google?

They would only bite a golden hand anyway.

> We are also concerned that it may infringe Oracle's copyrights in ZFS.

The Software Freedom Conservancy saying that is a bit scary. I am somewhat less afraid of Linux copyright holders suing.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by jldugger on Saturday May 14, 2016 @12:21PM (#11696765)
I wouldn't be surprised if the Canonical is taking a calculated risk here that Oracle doesn't actually care, or would be actively helpful if it meant spiting Redhat.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by pilif on Saturday May 14, 2016 @03:10PM (#11697597)
Of course Oracle also owns part of the copyright to the kernel. They still employ some kernel developers. And oracle could certainly sue distributors for violating their copyright (not on zfs, but on Linux)
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by tzs on Saturday May 14, 2016 @04:47PM (#11697964)
> Nevertheless, there may be arguments for contributory and/or indirect copyright infringement in many jurisdictions

In the United States there are two kinds of indirect infringement: contributory infringement and vicarious infringement.

Contributory infringement can occur when you know that someone else is or will directly infringe, and you substantially aid that by inducing, causing, or materially aiding their direct infringement. That can include providing the tools and equipment they use to infringe.

Vicarious infringement can occur when someone who is a direct infringer is your agent or under your control.

A very important aspect of both of these types of indirect infringement is that they make you liable for the direct infringement of someone else. If there is no someone else who is a direct infringer, then you cannot possibly be a contributory or vicarious infringer.

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by belorn on Saturday May 14, 2016 @05:38PM (#11698149)
In Sweden, the Pirate Bay tried and failed using a similar argument. The court instead found a law that targeted biker bars, where a law had been created to make it easier to shut down such facilities and prosecute its owners under contributory crimes. The prosecutor only need to convince the court that the average use is primary of a criminal nature, which in the Pirate Bay case consisted of a screenshot of the top 100 list. There didn't need to be someone that was found guilty of an actual infringement.
Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by pmoriarty on Saturday May 14, 2016 @12:39PM (#11696870)
"Downstream users should consider carefully before engaging in even source-only distribution."

Why would Free/open-source distros have to distribute ZFS source code? Couldn't they simply provide a method for downloading the source from the already existing ZFS repos and then compile the source? Wouldn't that be enough?

Re:ZFS lands in Debian contrib by ryao on Sunday May 15, 2016 @01:09AM (#11699537)
DKMS seems sufficient to make even the handful of guys with extreme legal positions happy. So far, none of them have come up with a way of saying it is not okay in their statements to the rest of us that think binaries are fine.