News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by nfnaaron on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:18AM (#1169522)
Why is IP being allowed to take precedence over civil liberties and cultural inheritance these days? WTF?
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by ulf on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:47AM (#1169601)
Because nobody makes any money with civil liberties...

"Police will have powers to enter private homes and seize posters, and will be able to stop people carrying non-sponsor items to sporting events." The second part is just as scary in my opinion

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by uygtfgh on Friday March 05, 2010 @03:55PM (#1170467)
They had that power and more for Vancouver. They even copyrighted a line from the national anthem.

What made Vancouver such a success is the low key policing. 6000 police + RCMP + army and they made 93 arrests (mostly drunk+disorderly), one policeman was slightly hurt when he broke a window stopping a fight. The result is the best press for the VPD in living memory.

Now picture the Met's response to any sort of demo in London.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by jwecker on Friday March 05, 2010 @02:31PM (#1170244)
If the venue is privately owned the second part doesn't scare me. I believe any privately owned property has the right to refuse entry to anyone they wish, and that that right trumps civil liberties. WHICH is why the first part of the story is a terrifying encroachment on liberty. No warrant? No laws broken? To have them simply enter and dictate what you're allowed to display on your own property? No way to refuse entry?
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by regularfry on Saturday March 06, 2010 @07:47AM (#1171465)
What's frightening is that it's specifically a police power. If the private property owner wants to enforce private rules, they should pay for private security guards to do it. Why should public money be used for this?

EDIT: On further thought, it's worse. The article implies that police will have the power to remove items from people on the way to an event. That would be hideous if true. I want a corroborative source before I get too worked up about this, though.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by nicoara on Sunday March 07, 2010 @08:40AM (#1173358)
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by regularfry on Monday March 08, 2010 @01:20PM (#1175956)
That corroborates one part but not the other, more worrying (but less likely) aspect.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by Quarrelsome on Friday March 05, 2010 @12:46PM (#1169912)
Yea but how many policeman are actually going to do that? They already refused changes to enable them to possess guns due to the problems it would cause them. I wonder if they'd refuse to do this or not, or just "pretend" to do it and not actually bother.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by jey on Friday March 05, 2010 @02:13PM (#1170191)
That's still way too close for comfort. "Oh, don't mind these laws, we don't actually enforce them except when it's really necessary. We're on your side! Just trust us."

It's just a small step from suddenly "needing" to question what constitutes "really necessary". We should be resisting tyranny as it creeps up on us, not remain complacent until after it becomes a true crisis.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by Periodic on Friday March 05, 2010 @01:06PM (#1169973)
I doubt anyone will be seizing your Pepsi if the games were sponsored by Coke, but they might have a case for not letting you set up your Pepsi-points gear under the coke sign.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by awa on Friday March 05, 2010 @08:38PM (#1170976)
This might happen and some sort of the does happen in Cricket. During the Cricket world cup the TV channel showing the event isn't allowed to show competitor's ads. Also, the players are not allowed to be part of any kind of competitor ad for the entire duration of the tournament. And yes, the English are used to this.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by ErrantX on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:54AM (#1169617)
Indeed - do you know if the Olympic grounds are public or private?
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by ulf on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:01AM (#1169640)
I would suspect they are private for the duration of the Games.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by dantheman on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:57AM (#1169626)
I hope their is a growing backlash to this type of behavior. I think more and more people are seeing the ridiculous positions of copyright holders and are losing respect for them. We see this in file sharing, and people upset that they cannot access content from another country -- eventually the IP laws will change.

I also think people are waking up to SCAM that is the olympics. The IOC is private organization that profits from the games, by stealing taxpayer money to fund their events. I don't know why anyone would want to host the olympics anymore.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by kanwisher on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:03AM (#1169645)
My home town Atlanta was a total ghetto before the Olympics, it forced the city to reinvest into the downtown and it has been vibrant and a nice place to live since then. Perhaps cities shouldn't wait till an olympics comes to rebuild the city ;)
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by CWuestefeld on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:09AM (#1169666)
Who actually paid to beautify your city? Was it cost-effective? Were there other ways the money could have been better spent?
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by danudey on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:41AM (#1169744)
Let's be honest; if Atlanta, on its own, dumped billions into revitalizing itself, no one would care except residents. Having a stage like the olympics to draw the world in, however, shows people the city and makes it more likely they will return.

Likewise with Vancouver; one of our major downtown streets, Granville, got a complete overhaul. Gone were the old, broken stones, the cracked sidewalks, the run-down streets and sickly trees. It's now a much better place to walk around and explore.

We also have a new mass-transit line connecting our downtown core with South Vancouver and Richmond, as well as the airport. Catching a flight used to be $25-35 by taxi, or god knows how much in parking. Now, it's about $4 per person, and that gets you there and back if you're dropping someone off. The project was a public-private partnership that was within budget and opened fifteen weeks early, and has made Richmond far easier to travel to and from (making everyone's life easier). The project was a no-brainer improvement to the region, but I doubt we would have had as much support and funding if we hadn't had the olympics coming to town.

Whether the other renovations to the city will prove useful, it's hard to tell yet, but I'm cautiously optimistic that they will.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by CWuestefeld on Friday March 05, 2010 @12:05PM (#1169821)
Olympics are rare enough that I don't know if any formal study has been done.

However, similar arguments are made all the time in support of building new sports stadiums. And at least in those cases, the arguments simply don't hold water: the beneficiary is the team ownership, NOT the taxpayers.

See http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-339es.html : The economic facts, however, do not support the position that professional sports teams should receive taxpayer subsidies. The lone beneficiaries of sports subsidies are team owners and players. ... Indeed, the results of studies on changes in the economy resulting from the presence of stadiums, arenas, and sports teams show no positive economic impact from professional sports -- or a possible negative effect.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by ible on Friday March 05, 2010 @02:14PM (#1170195)
Kind of aside the main discussion, but the Canada line was approved at 1.35 billion, cost 1.9 billion, and had it's scope significantly reduced in order to manage that. It being a p3 allowed hiding 'competitive' information such as cheaper but disruptive construction and single track sections from the public, and the cities involved until after it was approved. I like having new mass transit, but I'm not sure this can be used as an argument for the economic benefits of the olympics. Though it could be an argument that the olympics give political cover to push through large projects irrespective of the problems/benefits and that may or may not come out well.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by derefr on Friday March 05, 2010 @12:38PM (#1169894)
I don't know if you can say the new line made commuting around Vancouver any easier—more modernized, perhaps, but until it opened there were bus lines running down the same "track" with the same carrying capacities/latencies (98s and 424s.) They also removed many long-distance "shortcut" buses in the process, meaning that getting from, say, 1 Rd. in Richmond to Granville & Broadway turned from one bus to three (2 + the train line.) It was definitely extra capacity required for the Olympic duration, but it's mostly a wash now that it's over.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by jhancock on Friday March 05, 2010 @01:08PM (#1169976)
Other ways to spend the money? Well, anyone living in Atlanta now will tell you this winter's rainfall showed them just how bad the city's sewer system is. Its well known that Atlanta has major sewer problems for perhaps 100 years...think "massive sink holes that can suck down an entire building".

When your spending on beautification to show the world your city for 3 weeks, major infrastructure projects like sewer systems aren't high on the list.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by thechangelog on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:29AM (#1169715)
I can't believe your comment was downvoted. These are very valid questions.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by jhancock on Friday March 05, 2010 @01:02PM (#1169959)
I'm from Georgia and moved to Atlanta in '87 to go to Georgia Tech. I was a part of the student group that put together the Olympic bid. I stayed in Atlanta through the '96 games. My view is different than yours.

I do feel Atlanta did a good job hosting the '96 Olympics. However, your perspective that "Atlanta was a total ghetto before the Olympics" is far off. The "ghettos" can be restated as "poor black communities". These did not go away. They just relocated. This gentrification process was in place prior to the Olympic prep. The prep simply added more money to accelerate the process.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by anigbrowl on Friday March 05, 2010 @12:37PM (#1169893)
What I wonder is why they go about it so badly and stupidly. By chance, I took part in one of the first guerilla marketing exercises of this type about 20 years ago. Af enduring a night in the rain waiting to buy tickets for a tennis match at London's wimbledon, in the morning some nice people came along with a bunch of Batman t-shirts (the Time burton version was just being released) and of course chilly wet tennis fans were delighted to have another layer of clothing - and there were lots of Batman logos in the crowd when the match was televised later that day.

I understand organizers of sporting events and people who have paid a lot of money for broadcast rights (public money, in the case of the BBC) don't want to give free advertising to other brands surfing on the popularity of the Olympics...but surely the way to approach this is to hold the brand owners responsible, and agree that organized displays outside normal commercial channels (front gardens vs. billboards along a marathon route, say) are the commercial equivalent of graffiti.

Letting police come into people's houses because they can see objectionable material from the outside will end in tears. Sure, it's inappropriate if someone decks their house with ads for candy or cheap beer, but between poorly-drafted rules and over-enthusiastic police officers, I feel pretty certain that non-commercial displays of everything from political views to portraits of people who look overly sad or gloomy will become grounds for police censorship.

I lived in the UK for about a decade and loved it. But between the plethora of security cameras and things like this, I just can't imagine living there now. Neither Labor and Conservative governments over the years have shown any real respect for civil liberties.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by cturner on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:56AM (#1169792)
All IP always takes precedence over civil liberties in all cases. It is an anti-right by its nature.

There's a similar but less extreme generalisation to be made about its effect on cultural inheritance.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by ulf on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:35AM (#1169729)
Thinking some more about this, I come to the conclusion that there is only one way to incorporate civil liberties into nowadays world: We need an international tax that companies and organziations pay whenever they prune civic rights. Hard to get that one through all kinds of legislature, but I think it might work, once done.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by philwelch on Friday March 05, 2010 @02:54PM (#1170309)
The problem is when governments violate civil liberties, and you can't fix that by making a bigger government to enforce laws against the smaller governments.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by lucifer on Friday March 05, 2010 @12:01PM (#1169808)
That's not the winning attitude.

We shouldn't have to beg to have our rights (back). Just remember how you got those rights in the first place.

Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by nfnaaron on Friday March 05, 2010 @12:36PM (#1169892)
Some would say (have said, actually) that we never got them in the first place; we have them by nature, and we can only keep them or lose them.
Re:2012 Olympics: Police to enter private homes to remove po... by lucifer on Friday March 05, 2010 @11:48AM (#1169756)
Its basically a weasel strategy to keep "civil rights" on the books, yet practically emasculating those same rights in the courts. Welcome to global fascism.

(Remember fascism means the union of the corporate and the state. Egomaniacs in funny uniforms and goose stepping is optional.)

[grammar]