Re:Effect of Acute Exercise on Prostate Cancer Cell Growth (...
by craigyk on Saturday May 14, 2016 @02:10PM
(#11697341)
Well said. I find it disappointing how many cancer researchers delight in their arcane knowledge of cell line characteristics and will debate heartily about which is the right model for an experiment, so at the end of the day other cancer researchers can review their work and nod approvingly about their choice of cell lines, etc. These cells are exceedingly unnatural, even by the standards of cancer cells, and their extensive use in research now far exceeds their ability to tell us things that are meaningful about cancer in the body (IMO). I understand science requires reproducibility, and (in principle at least) cell line work is more reproducible... but I'm worried were chasing red herrings. If you are using cell lines to do basic research on a very specific subsystems, that is likely OK, but so much research these days is "translational" and involves observing cell-wide changes and reactions.
Re:Effect of Acute Exercise on Prostate Cancer Cell Growth (...
by mazsa on Saturday May 14, 2016 @02:15AM
(#11694750)
check those who are citing them with the keyword 'oxygen': https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=oxygen&cites=1233997312... (or without it: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?&cites=123399731234947157... )
Re:Effect of Acute Exercise on Prostate Cancer Cell Growth (...
by niels_olson on Sunday May 15, 2016 @05:50PM
(#11702932)
If you're referring to the results about VO2max, please bear in mind that growing cells in culture has nothing to do with that. The issue is that cells generally accumulate far less oxidative damage when grown at 3% oxygen, as compared to atmospheric (21%). So, perhaps they did grow them at low oxygen tension, but it doesn't seem like that's the case from their methods.
That said, interesting idea. I noted in the methods that the cells were not grown in low-oxygen conditions, and I'm wondering, if the authors are listening, why they didn't do that.