Ask HN: Can a startup be bootstrapped collaboratively by a group of people?
Can a start-up be founded not by 2-3 people who know each other in advance but by a group of random people as in case of community supported Open-Source projects?
The advantage of the latter I see is the fact you don't have to care about other people's background, experience, whatever as long as they bring enough value in a form of contribution. No need for vesting and cliffs. You contribute something, you get X shares.
A Github like platform for collaborative bootstrapping of start-ups could be created. Unlike the founderdating services that marry off multiple founders into each other so they can create something together, in this model founders are married into ideas/projects directly.
In your opinion how viable is this model?
(
13 comments
| 3 points
| on HN
)
While in theory it sounds good. It has huge holes that would need to be covered, and by the time you start covering those holes you have gone back to the reason you need things like vesting and cliffs in the first place.
How do you determine what the contribution itself is worth in terms of shares? How do you handle dilution? How do you handle co-founder disagreements? What happens if an early contributor leaves after a month? What happens to their shares? What happens if the company needs to take funding? How do you handle stock grants? The list of questions goes on and on, and by the time you account for all the questions, paid an attorney to address them all, you might as well have just created a traditional company.
The different with open-source is there is no "expectation" of financial gain from contributing. Once you start mixing a financial aspect you will have individuals with different goals and intentions. That's a bad mix in my opinion.
You probably need to look into history to learn what happens. You don't even need to look that far back. There was a company called Assembly http://www.theverge.com/2014/11/21/7258667/assembly-collabor... They shut down.
In my opinion creating these decentralized organizations is not that hard but they will never be able to win against centralized competitors who have clear incentive to win. Only time this approach can win is when there's no money involved since the re is no personal "incentive" to motivate the centralized organizations.
Why not? Cannot decentralized organizations also have incentive to win?
1. How are decision made? Can you appeal?
2. Is it a seniority based system or a lowest bid type system? or both?
3. How are the day to day things taken care of? customer support, etc. paid out?
4. Legal framework? International laws?
5. can shares be bought and sold?
6. focus and long term goals?
btw, my contact info is in my profile if any one is interested in moving forward.
P.S.: I'll absolutely get in touch with you.