You could start added loopholes to your "block loopholes" law, like "If you reside in the property, it's tax free", but then you hit problems like parents given their kids properties as tax shelters, and the like.
If there are unlikely seniors on fixed incomes with houses worth more than $10M, then they may pay this tax with shares in said house.
When their heirs come into possession of that house, they have to buy those shares back. 15 years of tax will be 1,5% market price.
It would either generate additional revenue or have them move to an area with cheaper houses/properties to avoid paying it, which would make space for young professionals who otherwise would not be able to afford it.
I'm also venturing to speculate that a lot of seniors are NIMBYs, facilitating the lack of affordable development and re-zoning, in which case that's another argument to get them the hell out of their expensive suburbia.
Think about what that'll do to your retirement. Presumably you're saving and such, and want to get to a point where you can live comfortably (not extravagantly) when you retire: a trip a couple times a year, the ability to take your grandkids to get ice cream, etc. A tax bill can be devastating to your retirement savings & therefore lifestyle.
Even in the US this is true, except to a less extreme extent. The systems the current seniors have put in place make sure few of the current workers will retire.
So why do they deserve it ? They voted in governments that fucked us, so why wouldn't we get to fuck them ?
IMO, you would need a much higher number. A 0.5% wealth tax AMT would = a 25% tax on a 2% ROI or 8.3% on a 6% ROI.
From an economic standpoint this is actually a good idea. People with lot's of unreolised income are often stuck with unproductive assets because selling them incurs a large tax bill. With this you can sell a reasonable chunk of your assets without incurring extra tax.
Nobody in the USA has the balls to propose or implement this.
It does make sense though. Why tax the guy making money? You should tax the guy hoarding it!
I've never understood why the capital gains tax rate is lower than the rate for normal income. Capital gains are basically money you earn for having money and not being an idiot with it. It's one of the major ways the rich get even richer just because they are rich and how the wealth gap widens.
From a 10,000 foot view it seems like it should be taxed at a higher rate than normal income, since theoretically the person had to actually work for their normal income which directly helped the economy and the country as a whole.
This is the Labor Theory of Value in another guise. Efficient allocation of resources is extremely important, and the LToV discounts that to having no value.
This is called 'investment'.
It takes a lot of effort and time to be good at it.
Also as long as inflation exists, one will need investments.
Call it all wealth and throw a % on it. Make it progressively increase up and 0% on anything less than $X. We could call it a Robin Hood tax.
This will also have the incentive of causing the wealthy to invest in riskier things. Ex: 5% growth doesn't make sense with a 6% wealth tax.
EDIT: Moved some sentences around.
Market does assessing net worth pretty good today.
I haven't said a word about making tax code harder. You can remove a LOT of tax code with this change.
Any policy that would cause people to be forced from their homes just because should be viewed as a failure.
I have a really really hard time feeling bad for people who bought homes in the bay area in ~1980. They won the lottery. Their home grew 10% y/y for 30 years outpacing inflation by a significant margin. They got a 30 year tax break while their income likely outpaced inflation as well because they live in an extremely good job market. That house they bought for 100k is now worth 1.7 Million. They can sell the home, move basically anywhere else in the country, and retire on the remaining gain. Yeah, I'm having a hard time feeling too bad for them.
On the other hand, the person who moved to SF in 1980 and decided to rent, I feel bad for them. Unless they found a rent controlled apartment, they've seen their rents grow 10% y/y, and if they found a rent controlled apartment they probably got evicted when the owners of the property sold it, and the new owners decided they wanted to redo the property as condos.
Lets just call it what it is, rent control for rich people. Then maybe we'll talk about it sensibly and realize that it's a horribly thought out plan.
>>On the other hand, the person who moved to SF in 1980 and decided to rent, I feel bad for them.
Instead of punishing people for being successful. The latter people should ponder on their foolishness, instead of blaming other people for being more intelligent.
Last time I check making good decisions about one's future is not a vice.
In real world, you can always bootstrap your way to a decent nest egg, whether its a retirement fund or a home. It takes time, and it takes hard work. But is very possible and a lot of people do it.
If you can't, then evaluate your spending patterns seriously. I haven't met any person yet who didn't have wasteful expenditure that couldn't be eliminated.
More often than not its not the means/resources, its lack of resourcefulness. People in general don't have the motivation to take steps towards solving a difficult problem, and the discipline to suffer through a grind and see it through to the end. This of course is a very different problem, the responsibility of which starts and ends at a individual alone.
People who are poor or improvised deserve to live a life that also allows them to have something enjoyable, including hobbies. It shouldn't beconsidered a lack of discipline that an impoverished person could maybe enjoy their life once in a while. It's depressing how much one can expect a life of misery of they're poor.
No, not really. Especially given housing prices now.
You have now to choose between growing your house value or nurturing your career.
Tax 0,1% of net worth of those whose net worth exceeds say $10 million. Such people have to get assessment of their net worth and then pay their tax.
Of course they have incentive on doing slightly funny things with their net worth, but it is difficult to race them to the bottom in view of very large fines for crossing the line.
Of course people will skip citizenship then; but as long as they do business within country it is solvable too.