Re:Eric S. Raymond - The Curse of the Gifted (2000)
by dkarl on Thursday March 04, 2010 @06:00PM
(#1168317)
His reasoning smacks of a religious/political debate: given two complementary destructive human tendencies, we should direct all our concern and condemnation at one, because the one is a seductive vice that threatens to run disastrously out of control, while the other is not so seductive and can be safely left to human judgment. See priggishness vs. debauchery, meanness vs. gullibility, paranoia vs. complacency, etc.
"On the whole, people tend to _want_ to share, because it ends up being the easier "quick hack" in many cases. So I'm not worried about that part overmuch. I'm worried about people who share even when it doesn't make sense. And I'm worried about people having bad interfaces, which makes even sensible sharing end up as a experiment in horror.
That's why I'm so un-interested in the "let's share" argument. I don't think that is where the problems are. "