News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by kylec on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @04:39PM (#11679054)
Electric cars are quiet, it's conceivable that he was walking away, unaware his car was moving behind him.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by freehunter on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @04:47PM (#11679119)
But enabling Summon mode is not quiet nor automatic. It's a manual process and it dings and shows a light on the dashboard. Tesla is saying the guy turned on Summon mode in a place where he wasn't supposed to, in a situation it was never designed to work in, and that's why the driver is at fault. The software worked as designed, but the driver didn't pay attention to its limitations.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @04:54PM (#11679179)
The software did not work as designed, because it is designed, above all else, to not hit stationary objects.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @04:58PM (#11679209)
That's not true. The software is designed to work under human supervision, and the autonomous collision avoidance is a supplement to that supervision, not a substitute.

You could certainly argue that the software should be designed to, above all else, not hit stationary objects. But it is not actually designed that way.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:02PM (#11679241)
> That's not true. The software is designed to work under human supervision

It was not designed to work under human supervision, but even if it was, that design was wrong, and the design was broken from the start.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:05PM (#11679260)
What is your basis for the statement that it was not designed to work under human supervision? The documentation is quite explicit about needing human supervision, and I see nothing whatsoever indicating anything otherwise.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:16PM (#11679369)
https://www.teslamotors.com/models

"Digital control of motors, brakes, and steering helps avoid collisions from the front and sides, and prevents the car from wandering off the road."

It's designed to avoid collisions from the front and sides.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:21PM (#11679414)
The use of the word "helps" makes it pretty clear that it's not intended to be the only thing working to avoid collisions.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:22PM (#11679425)
No it doesn't.

And you're still ignoring the part where I said it doesn't matter if it was designed intentionally this way or not, it shouldn't behave this way, regardless.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:26PM (#11679450)
Really, you think that "X helps Y" is compatible with X being intended as the sole thing performing Y? If so, we clearly speak fundamentally different languages, despite the superficial similarities in spelling and such.

As for ignoring the other part, I explicitly acknowledged in my original reply that this would be a valid criticism, and it's not something I feel strongly enough about to argue.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:31PM (#11679480)
I didn't say "x being intended as the sole thing performing Y", I said, "It's designed to avoid collisions from the front and sides.", which it was.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:36PM (#11679526)
You said it's designed to work without human supervision. Unless you're proposing some third entity besides the car and the human which would be responsible for collision avoidance, then what you said is that the car is fully responsible for it.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:38PM (#11679543)
> You said it's designed to work without human supervision.

When?

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:40PM (#11679553)
"It was not designed to work under human supervision...."

I don't know how else to understand that other than that it was designed to work without human supervision. If that's not what you meant, perhaps you could elaborate.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:44PM (#11679583)
I meant what I said. Collision detection was not designed to work under human supervision, which means when it runs into something, it has failed its design.

Tesla cars are not designed to run into things.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by simoncion on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:38PM (#11680278)
> Collision detection was not designed to work under human supervision, which means when it runs into something, it has failed its design.

From your quote upthread:

> "Digital control of motors, brakes, and steering helps avoid collisions from the front and sides, and prevents the car from wandering off the road."

(Emphasis mine.)

Notice the shift in language from "helps avoid" to "prevents" when describing the two different aspects of the car's thrust and positioning systems. The different is significant and important. It's clear that the systems are a front and side collision assistance system, not a front and side collision prevention system.

You see the distinction?

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:11PM (#11680652)
I see the distinction you're trying to make, but it's not referencing the design.

Are you suggesting collision detection is not designed to prevent collisions?

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by simoncion on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:40PM (#11680763)
> Are you suggesting collision detection is not designed to prevent collisions?

Lol. Okay, dude.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by freehunter on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:50PM (#11680339)
Is your name Jared Overton? Or is that the name of your client? Because no impartial person would be so deliberately dense to argue against his own words.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:12PM (#11680656)
Relax, I'm just trying to point out that Tesla did not intend to build a car that would run into stationary objects.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by cynix on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:56AM (#11681605)
They also did not build their car to never run into objects. These 2 are not mutually exclusive.

For example, a kitchen knife is not designed to kill people, but it also wasn't designed to prevent itself from being used to kill people.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by freehunter on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:46PM (#11680319)
I mean, my laptop is designed to detect a fall and park the hard drive automatically to avoid damage. But if I throw it off a cliff, it's probably still going to get damaged, and the Western Digital is going to laugh at my warranty claim. Because the software worked as designed, I just ignored the limitations and took the hardware outside of the design spec. Yes, the hard drive can protect against falls, up to a certain amount of G forces. Yes the Tesla can move itself around stationary objects, within the limitations of where the sensors can read.

I think you need to reevaluate your definition of "as designed". Because it's pretty clear that the Tesla was not designed to avoid this collision. It's not a software failure.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:12PM (#11680660)
The Tesla was designed to avoid this collision. Are you trying to say that Tesla would prefer their car hit stuff?
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by cynix on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:35AM (#11681520)
> The Tesla was designed to avoid this collision. Are you trying to say that Tesla would prefer their car hit stuff?

They don't prefer their car to hit stuff, but the car is not designed to never hit stuff either. By your logic, any car manufacturer that doesn't have some sort of collision prevention system prefer their cars to hit stuff, which is absurd.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:06PM (#11684409)
That's not my logic, it's the logic of the comment I replied to. What I'm trying to say is they specifically designed and built a collision detection system with the goal of preventing the car from hitting things parked in front of it. That collision detection system did not detect the collision that took place in this case, and failed in its design goal, it's raison d'etre.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by cynix on Thursday May 12, 2016 @08:52PM (#11687885)
The car is designed to prevent collisions that can be detected by the sensors. This particular collision could not be detected by the sensors, therefore it isn't possible for the car to prevent it.

Are you basically saying a bulletproof vest has failed to achieve its design goal if it can't stop armour-piercing rounds? Or a fire extinguisher has failed to achieve its design goal if it can't put out a wild forest fire? There are always limitations to everything.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by dimino on Friday May 13, 2016 @03:03PM (#11692501)
I'm saying Tesla engineers aren't looking at this and throwing their hands up in the air, claiming this was supposed to happen, and I'm saying a bulletproof vest has failed to achieve its design goal if you can't wear it when it's wet.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by kylec on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:00PM (#11679224)
From the accounts here, it sounds like it's pretty easy to activate Summon when you just want to park your car, by accidentally pressing "park" twice instead of once. This is compounded by the fact that there is no "off" for Teslas, you're expected to park it and get out. Sure, there might be dings and dashboard lights, but I can easily see how someone might not see them, or might not know what they signify is about to happen. Finally, as far as I'm aware, there is no external sound or indication that the car is in Summon mode, it just starts to move, so I can easily see how, once you exit the vehicle, you'd be unaware of it happening behind you.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:04PM (#11679254)
Activating Summon by double-clicking the Park button is an optional feature that's off by default. In addition, Summon itself is an optional feature that's off by default. Both settings come with warnings about appropriate use. So while the feature is fairly easy to activate once you have the settings enabled, the easy answer to it is to leave it disabled.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by kylec on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:11PM (#11679324)
Is it possible that those safeguards were deactivated by the Tesla delivery specialist, or by the customer at the suggestion of the delivery specialist, in order to demonstrate how the feature works? I genuinely don't know if that's something the delivery specialists do, but I think it's plausible. Tesla demonstrates Autopilot on test drives as a matter of course, and I could easily see them wanting to demonstrate Summon to new customers.

If so, I think it's possible the customer was not made aware of the safety implications and limitations of the system.

Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by mikeash on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:13PM (#11679349)
It's possible, in that it's not against the laws of physics or anything. I've never heard of anyone having such things enabled by anyone from Tesla, though, and I suspect that if they did it for this person, he'd be telling everyone who will listen.
Re:Tesla Model S autonomously crashes into a parked trailer ... by tclmeelmo on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @05:21PM (#11679411)
It would also seem possible for a spouse or other alternate driver of the car to have disabled those safeguards.