Re:Moxie Marlinspike Makes Encryption for Everyone
by haffenloher on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @06:46PM
(#11679992)
> Are you in the right thread? The discussion here is about what information Google can get from GCM messages
The parent poster of the post you initially replied to asserted that Signal was "giving NSA the only thing what they want: metadata from Google", so I guess that's where tptacek is coming from.
On a side note, Google can't actually know the message sizes because GCM is used without a payload.
Re:Moxie Marlinspike Makes Encryption for Everyone
by tptacek on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:56PM
(#11680367)
Yes, but they're right: we started talking past each other several comments ago. Sorry!
And even though your question is off-topic, I already answered it above.
Why would you accuse someone of being allergic to a technology when they are simply answering questions about it? If you disagree with the actual topic of discussion - that Google (not the NSA) might get more than just "message sizes and timestamps" out of an E2E-encrypted app which uses GCM messages - then have a normal conversation about it instead of bringing up the NSA repeatedly.
And if not, then stop making baseless and inflammatory accusations.