Re:Think like a statistician, without the math
by joe_the_user on Thursday March 04, 2010 @02:44PM
(#1167838)
My degree is in math too.
I think the article is bogus and kind of dangerous.
Math is a matter of exact calculation. If the axioms are true, the premises will follow. Statistics seems like math but involves a group of hidden assumptions about "the world". It's crucial to know the difference between the two fields.
Like mathematics, statistics offers an array of machinery producing results. Unlike mathematicians, statistician should be "gate keepers" as well as technicians. Ideally, a statistician should be there to say "just because you can your stock market data into a heat equation, it doesn't mean you should plug your stock market data in a heat equation".
Unfortunately, the article seems to entirely neglect this aspect except in banalities that a non-math person would be entirely incapable of applying ("dig deeper" won't help you if you don't know why normal distributions matter and why not everything is normal).
I think the article is bogus and kind of dangerous.
Math is a matter of exact calculation. If the axioms are true, the premises will follow. Statistics seems like math but involves a group of hidden assumptions about "the world". It's crucial to know the difference between the two fields.
Like mathematics, statistics offers an array of machinery producing results. Unlike mathematicians, statistician should be "gate keepers" as well as technicians. Ideally, a statistician should be there to say "just because you can your stock market data into a heat equation, it doesn't mean you should plug your stock market data in a heat equation".
Unfortunately, the article seems to entirely neglect this aspect except in banalities that a non-math person would be entirely incapable of applying ("dig deeper" won't help you if you don't know why normal distributions matter and why not everything is normal).