He doesn't like how F-Droid uses centralized signing keys which are stored online: https://github.com/WhisperSystems/Signal-Android/issues/127#...
It would be more work for him of course, maintaining a repo and pushing updates to two locations, but I don't think it would be too much extra work and it sounds like a lot of people are looking for a non-GP repo. Pushing to your own server is easier than updating in an app market anyday.
At the end of the day, he can of course spend his time how he wants, I just think there's a loud if not large group that would like a Google Play Services-less Signal.
Some people are clearly angry, but it seems that this is yet another case where people are angry because they don't understand the GPL or don't understand the situation (or both).
I download things from F-Droid, mostly for convenience and security since I get notified about updates, but I understand it is another person/group I need to trust. I trust, for whatever reason, that they will build directly from source and update frequently.
Ways this could go, as I see it:
0. Moxie's code, moxie's build, Google's repo - The current way I know of getting moxie's build, but you have to trust Google as well.
1. Moxie's code, moxie's build, moxie's repo - I think this would be best, and what I was talking about.
2. Moxie's code, fdroid'd build, fdroid's repo - what I would also like, but moxie publicly discourages unofficial builds so fdroid doesn't want to touch it. Up to them.
2b. Moxie's code, moxie's build, fdroid's repo - a hypothetical some people have floated, but fdroid won't host binaries they haven't built from source and I don't blame them and moxie wouldn't provide an official build outside of Gplay either way.
3. Moxie's code modified with new name by 3rd party, 3rd party's build, 3rd party's repo - eutopia.cz's build and repo. Another person to trust to build correctly and update frequently
I don't think it's just some people being angry. I think things could be better, but it doesn't sound like they will. Moxie wants F-Droid to provide services similar to what GPServices provides before he'll do 1. F-Droid will never do this(hopefully). So we have to live with 0 or 3. I think scenario 1 > 3 > 0, other people think otherwise.
Isn't FOSS fun?
Response from actual FDroid dev:
> It's connected to the network, yes
[1] https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...
Since he signs it with his own key, nobody can force an auto-upgrade except him. So you either have to trust him for this version and all future versions, or not trust him and build your own. You can package and sign your own version, but apparently (I haven't actually seen the reported twitter comments) he doesn't want you to name them the same (which is clearly a reasonable trademark issue since any build not signed by him could contain anything).
I personally don't have a problem with that and it certainly isn't a GPL violation.
You can distribute the same build on F-Droid and Play, and also signed with your own key, if you use proper reproducible builds
(And not the TextSecure variant of "let’s download this huge image and let it compile the app", because that opens you to evil compiler issues).
I'm trying to remember how Android works, but I seem to recall that you need to sign the packages differently on Play and Fdroid. So you literally can't redistribute the same Play package with Fdroid (someone correct me if I'm wrong). This means rebuilding... and hence rebranding.
It seems that MM was asked to provide a build for Fdroid. He decided not to. That's completely his right. He doesn't go into a lot of detail about why he has decided this, but it's completely up to him.
So all I can tell is that there is an Fdroid version, which has a different name. You can't switch easily between the Play and Fdroid versions because of code suckage... which sucks, but isn't a GPL violation.
Is this just a tempest in a teapot, or am I missing something?