Oh, that's a great point about the insurance implications. There are also coordination issues, if you read the first comment on the blog post...
And what if the person you're riding with is too chatty and you just wanted to nap the whole ride? :)
On the other hand, I know that there's nothing wrong (insurance-wise) with accepting gas money from a friend... and, to push it further, if a friend of a friend needed a lift somewhere that I was already going, my insurance would probably be fine with that, and I'd definitely accept gas money in that situation...