News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tutorial On Designing/Building A PCB (Using FOSS) by Animats on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:20PM (#11671760)
KiCAD does seem to have a tediousness problem. The tutorial shows a process for creating a new parts library which requires far too many steps - saving some random part into a new library to create it, telling the part designer about the new library, and starting from a blank part which has text in the way of what you're creating.

Also, moving something by holding "M" and dragging with the mouse seems a holdover from the DOS era. Of course, if you don't like that, you can remap the hotkeys. That's so open-source.

Re:Tutorial On Designing/Building A PCB (Using FOSS) by mng2 on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @02:00AM (#11672926)
Electronic CAD is tedium, honestly. Even the expensive stuff I use at work is tedious, which is why we have a PCB layout department.

I haven't used KiCAD for several years, but in the past I used Rohrbacher's Quick Library Builder [0] to generate parts. Otherwise making parts is indeed a pain.

I enjoy KiCAD's single-key commands, though.

0: http://kicad.rohrbacher.net/quicklib.php

Re:Tutorial On Designing/Building A PCB (Using FOSS) by svens_ on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:33PM (#11671815)
That's exactly what I was thinking - the footprint editor is horrible in that aspect.

You don't have to hold "M" to move, it picks up the component when pressing.

The shortcuts in general are not as nicely placed as Altium, e.g. Zoom-to-fit (Home) is very awkward. Sure you can change that, but stuff like this requires a lot of time and the setup will be incompatible with other people (and one might have to adapt it on the next update, etc.).

Re:Tutorial On Designing/Building A PCB (Using FOSS) by taneq on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:25PM (#11671783)
You don't have to hold 'm', you can just press it while hovering over a component. Just like you can in the schematic except the hotkey is 'g'. Or you can do in the OpenGL PCB renderer (but not the default renderer) with a simple click-and-drag. Oh and you can't undo/redo in track laying mode even if you're not laying a track.

The user interface is insanely fragmented, is what I'm getting at.