News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1,284 Newly Validated Kepler Planets by dmix on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:36PM (#11671249)
Is there any reasoning why the distribution of planet sizes aren't following a bell curve or similar pattern? Maybe due to what materials the planets are composed of puts them into separated size categories?

https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/thumbnails/image/fi...

Re:1,284 Newly Validated Kepler Planets by TrevorJ on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:42PM (#11671273)
No idea how valid this is, but it might be because this data set is populated only by planets that one very particular piece of hardware can spot.
Re:1,284 Newly Validated Kepler Planets by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:57PM (#11671908)
The main reason Kepler can only see specific kinds of planets is that you need to see three transits before you confirm it, and that the further out a planet is from it's star, the less likely it is that it will ever transit.

These two combine to make planets closer to the sun much more likely to be seen. If there was another Sol in a perfect place and at perfect alignment and Kepler had been looking straight at it, by now we would have detected Mercury, Earth, Venus and Mars but nothing else.

Re:1,284 Newly Validated Kepler Planets by nikdaheratik on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:50AM (#11672713)
The graph isn't uniformly distributed by radius, for one thing, as it has 0.5R-3.1 Re divided into four different bars, with 3.1-22 Re divided into the other four, so it wouldn't look like a bell curve even if they were normally distributed as it's designed to highlight planet sizes that are closer to earth sized.

Also, as someone mentioned, Kepler is only likely to find planets fairly close to their star. And if you have several large planets that are close to their star, they are more likely to interact and be knocked out into a higher orbit until only one is left to dominate the orbits close in. Smaller planets are less likely to disturb the orbits of their neighbors which means a system is more likely to have several smaller planets closer into the star, which again, makes them more likely to be detected by Kepler.

[edited for clarity]

Re:1,284 Newly Validated Kepler Planets by simcop2387 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:23PM (#11671479)
As with the sibling post, I'd also wonder if it's because of the failures that Kepler has had. Right now it can only point at a really small part of the sky and it's possible that that star forming region just happened to form mostly smaller planets.

Horrible armchair speculation: the graph ALMOST looks like there's two bell curves summed together. a larger planet forming one and a smaller planet forming one, might indicate that there's some threshold for making larger planets that has to be crossed first.