good point :) However it makes a slight assumption that you still have 95% chance of winning if you hand over the wallet and are then attacked.
This is probably not the case as the attacker gains a reasonable advantage by being first (maybe only 2 or 3% in this case)
I also assumed the 50% was referring to the percentage chance of being actually harmed rather than having to fight. In which case your stats do break down.
P( no injury | fight ) = 95%.
P( injury | hand over wallet ) = P(injury | fight) P(fight | hand over wallet) = 0.05 x 0.5 = 0.025
So P(no injury | hand over wallet) = 97.5%.