News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by Pitarou on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:32AM (#11666176)
This is also a common complaint about Simple English books written for English learners. The books claim to have a restricted vocabulary, but they cheat by using phrasal verbs.

Their vocabulary includes verbs like put and set along with prepositions like up, with and upon. You can combine these to generate an enormous number of phrasal verbs like put up with, set upon and so on, which are normally considered to be separate vocabulary items.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by JorgeGT on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:52AM (#11666235)
As a person whose first language is not English, I find phrasal verbs one of the most challenging parts of the language. In fact I just searched set upon and was greatly surprised that it means attacking violently! I would have never guessed that from the words alone.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by gotodengo on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:38AM (#11666468)
In this case the phrase is a more artistic way of describing the beginning of a fight. Think of "John set upon Mike angrily" as John set, or selected, Mike as his target.

It's also a great example of the topic at hand because the same phrase could be used like "The book was set upon the table." Describing a book that was placed on a table.

Each version uses the same common vocabulary, to describe wildly different things.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by johnlbevan2 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:30AM (#11666708)
Or phonetically similar / by moving a space:

"John was set up on a date" - someone arranged a romantic encounter for John. "John was setup on a date" - on some specific day John was assembled. "John was set upon a date" - John assaulted a piece of fruit.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by FlyingAvatar on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:54AM (#11667131)
> "John was setup on a date" - on some specific day John was assembled.

I read this one as: A romantic encounter was the guise by which John was framed for a crime.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by Pitarou on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:42PM (#11668529)
Nice try :-), but there's a reason why we write "upon" without a space. In normal speech the prosody makes it perfectly clear that "upon" is one word, rather than two.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by Bjartr on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:55AM (#11666803)
My read of the last one is that it means "John was set upon [getting] a date"
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by nkrisc on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:46AM (#11666768)
Who is this romantic android enemy of fruit?
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by oddsignals on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:57AM (#11666812)
John.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by aptwebapps on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:45AM (#11666763)
The last one made me laugh but you need to remove the 'was'.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:41AM (#11667027)
No, it still works. Someone else has caused John to assault the fruit. "The guard dog was set upon an intruder, while John was set upon a date."
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by kbenson on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:22PM (#11668337)
Doesn't the "was" change who the action applies to? E.g. "John assaulted a date" vs "John was assaulted by a date"? I'm not entirely sure "John was set upon a date" makes sense. Then again, I've never been great with the specific rules of English, even though it's my first language (likely because it's my first language, and I learned it not as rules, but through immersion as a child).
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by schoen on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:11PM (#11668773)
"Set upon" can mean either "to begin to attack" or "to cause to begin to attack", although in the latter case the target of attack goes between "set" and "upon":

The dog set upon the cat. (began to attack the cat)

The person set the dog upon the cat. (caused the dog to begin to attack the cat)

The second meaning could make sense in the original sentence with John being the attacker, a date (fruit) being the target of attack, and an unspecified party being the one who caused John to attack. In this case there is a past-tense passive with "was" + the past participle of the verb (like "was liked", "was seen", "was taken"), but the past participle of "set upon" is identical to the present form, so "was set upon" means either "was attacked" or was caused to attack. But only the second meaning is plausible when followed by "a date", as opposed to "by a date".

"John was set upon a date" → John was caused to attack a date

"John was set upon by a date" → John was attacked by a date

This reminds me that phrasal verbs really are one of the trickiest things in English. Some of my non-native speaker friends have several books just about this topic, because it's so subtle and pervasive in English.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by kbenson on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:30PM (#11668937)
Thank you for the clarification. I suspected the "by" portion might be key, mainly because it felt like it was missing (and thus a requirement). That it helps distinguish the meaning makes sense.

I really should spend some time to research the mechanics of my native tongue, rather than rely on what sounds right and the simplistic rules I can remember from primary school. This has been on my mental to-do list at different times over the years, but I always seem to have it de-prioritized and then I forget about it. :/

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by e12e on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @05:00PM (#11670616)
Just remember that language isn't truly normative - in general, one of the best tests for "correctness" is "appears in speech by native speakers". Which is somewhat complicated by the existence of written language. In English, Shakespeare is somewhat famously the inventor of a number of idioms that would probably seem strange at the time, but are now ingrained to the English language, see eg:

"You're quoting Shakespeare" - Rob Brydon reveals popular Shakespeare phrases in everyday use: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ig6f5fT0Xho

Or, "My Shakespeare - a new poem by Kate Tempest": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_auc2Z67OM

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by schoen on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:55PM (#11669145)
Sure. Another analogy without the phrasal verb might be "give", which has an indirect object:

John has given a date. (he stated when something would happen, or he donated a fruit to someone)

John was given a date. (he received a fruit as a gift)

John was given by a date. (most likely interpretation is that someone's romantic partner, maybe John's, nominated John for some position or role)

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by fenomas on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:09PM (#11668763)
GP means it in the sense of "The attack dog was set upon the intruder" (e.g. by its master).
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by tgb on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:01AM (#11667186)
Or, alternatively, it means that John was placed on top of a fruit.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by gohrt on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:23PM (#11671474)
"setup" is a noun form of "set up"
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by johnlbevan2 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:25AM (#11666678)
Whilst this ambiguity is a pain for those learning the language and for clarity, it's also one of the things which makes English a great language for puns/wordplay.

I suspect that having a reduced vocabulary would likely increase the chances of ambiguity, so could be a great source of CNL puns.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by toothbrush on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:21AM (#11666669)
Or, John was set upon going to the movies tonight, but his friend refused to join him.

Admittedly, that sounds a bit old-fashioned.

Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by jdmichal on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:39AM (#11667498)
Honestly any use of upon sounds old-fashioned. It's generally been replaced by on, except in a few contexts by up. Even Google defines it as "a more formal term for on".
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by ghaff on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:34AM (#11666723)
Set on is probably a bit more natural in that context although I'm not sure either is particularly common phraseology.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by Angostura on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:30AM (#11666424)
From what I recall, 'set' is the word in the English language which has most meanings - over 50.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by Pitarou on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:44PM (#11668549)
Depending on which dictionary you use, it's either put or set.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by e12e on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @05:04PM (#11670646)
Perhaps it's time to revisit some OO/database terms, to avoid things like: Person.set(up), db.put(down), set.contains(Person) ;-)
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by alanfalcon on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:28AM (#11666406)
Context helps: "His foe set upon him with such vigor that he knew he was hopelessly outmatched. He began to silently pray for assistance."
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by emartinelli on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:11AM (#11666311)
I remember when I was studying English in the U.S. with other foreign students some years ago, when the topic was phrasal verbs the grades decreased for entire class. I am Brazilian, the class was composed most of South Koreans and Saudi Arabians.
Re:The Controlled Natural Language of Randall Munroe's Thing... by schoen on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:02PM (#11671681)
Phrasal verbs are a hidden problem for estimating English vocabulary competence (as was alluded to earlier in this thread), because they play serious havoc with the idea of "knowing" a word. If you asked English learners if they knew the meanings of "work", "in", "out", and "off", most would say yes at a pretty early stage of their English education.

But that doesn't mean that they'd necessarily correctly interpret (or produce) "work in" 'incorporate (in a narrative or plan), "work out" 'resolve (a problem); deduce (a solution or consequence); deliberately perform physical exercise', "work off" 'eliminate (a debt, obligation, or excessive food intake) through effort'.

And there are hundreds more of those combinations with meanings that need to be learned independently.