News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programming by poking: why MIT stopped teaching SICP by jholman on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @05:07AM (#11665967)
> You need automata theory... Turing-completeness... PDAs and FSAs...

Why? I know that stuff inside and out, and across multiple jobs I have used none of it ever. What chance to use this favourite bit of my education did I miss? (Or rather, might I have missed, so that you might speak to the general case)

> You need to know how to compile a high-level language down to an RTL.

Why? Same comment as above.

> You need to understand what a fixed point is and why it matters.

Well, I don't, and I don't. I request a pointer to suitable study material, noting that googling this mostly points me to a mathematical definition which I suspect is related to, but distinct from, the definition you had in mind.

Otherwise... as I read down this thread I was all ready to disagree with you, but it turns out I'd jumped to a false conclusion, based on the SICP context of this thread. Literacy, what a pain in the butt.

In particular, the idea that ((the notion of an environment) is a fundamental/foundational concept) is a new idea to me, and immediately compelling. I did not learn this in my academic training, learned it since, and have found it be very fruitful. Likewise with lexical vs dynamic binding, actually.

Re:Programming by poking: why MIT stopped teaching SICP by lisper on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:31AM (#11667921)
>> You need automata theory... Turing-completeness... PDAs and FSAs...

> Why?

So you can write parsers. To give a real-world example, so you can know immediately why trying to parse HTML with a regular expression can't possibly work.

>> You need to know how to compile a high-level language down to an RTL.

>Why?

So that when your compiler screws up you can look at its output, figure out what it did wrong, and fix it.

>> You need to understand what a fixed point is and why it matters.

> Well, I don't, and I don't. I request a pointer to suitable study material

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-comput...

Particularly lectures 2A and 7A.