News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whatever happened to programming? by jrockway on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:58AM (#1166482)
My current project has so far required me to know about Python, Django, Google App Engine and it's datastore, XHTML, CSS, JQuery, Javascript, JSON, and a clutch of XML schema, APIs and the like.

This is the price you pay for being able to work with other people. If you never wanted to reuse anyone else's code or talk to anything else on the Internet, you would not need to know any of this. To stand on the shoulders of giants, you need to speak their language.

Re:Whatever happened to programming? by jey on Thursday March 04, 2010 @04:04AM (#1166491)
I think you missed the main thrust of his complaint: back when everyone was hacking in FORTRAN and COBOL, you really didn't need to know much more than the language, its standard library, and stuff specific to the problem you were solving. At worst maybe you'd have to learn BLAS and LAPACK if you were doing numerical stuff. The APIs/overhead/junk memorization situation has been steadily worsening since then.

But at least now we don't have to take a stack of punched cards to the Priest with an Offering (bribe) and wait a day just to get a printout saying that the damn thing dumped core.

Re:Whatever happened to programming? by gnosis on Thursday March 04, 2010 @06:33AM (#1166650)
You still have the option of using FORTRAN and COBOL with BLAS and LAPACK, if you're satisfied with the result.

The problem is that today we demand much more than what those earlier tools can give us. Such demands result in an inevitable (?) increase in complexity of the aggregate toolset. The tools are capable of more, and give you more options. So it seems that learning and using those tools effectively would be more challenging.

But it's not a one-way street. Along with this increase in complexity have been efforts to simplify, streamline, and structure these tools and ease their use. But both the demand for increased ease of learning/use and the demand for power are moving targets. Hopefully with time both could be maximized. We're just not there yet. Remember, computer science is still in its infancy.

Re:Whatever happened to programming? by jrockway on Thursday March 04, 2010 @05:18AM (#1166572)
Nobody is forcing you to want to interact with the real world.

The reality is that "back in the day", computers weren't useful to very many people. Now they are.

Re:Whatever happened to programming? by jey on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:04PM (#1167882)
You're taking a narrow definition of the "real world" by including webapps but excluding ATM machines.

I agree that all this "overhead" does have utility, I'm not saying we shouldn't have it -- but it's less pure/fun compared to the old stuff (IMO).

Re:Whatever happened to programming? by lollynoob on Thursday March 04, 2010 @10:40AM (#1167140)
"Standing on the shoulders of giants" is exactly what's wrong with programming, and technology in general. If we keep doing this, we'll eventually build up so much information that when the foundations (the "giants") need repair or improvement, nobody will know how to fix them. You should never rely on someone else's work without fully understanding it yourself, and in programming that usually means it's best to write things from scratch. There needs to be more praise for re-inventing the wheel.
Re:Whatever happened to programming? by arethuza on Thursday March 04, 2010 @10:59AM (#1167182)
Please tell me you are trolling.
Re:Whatever happened to programming? by lollynoob on Thursday March 04, 2010 @11:50AM (#1167335)
Why would I be trolling? Sure, it's an unpopular opinion, but I'm expressing it sincerely. The idea that you should continually build on the work of others is insane--do you build buildings like that? Constantly tacking on parts as they're needed, never re-analyzing the foundations? Of course not. Why, then, should the same work for software or science? All that results in is an excess of information; I'm suggesting that it's better to trim that excess by constantly rebuilding and refining the basics, rather than building monstrosities upon monstrosities.
Re:Whatever happened to programming? by whimsy on Thursday March 04, 2010 @08:51PM (#1168583)
Do you build buildings like that? You certainly do!

Please don't tell me each building project reinvents concrete, or steel girders, or cranes, et cetera, et cetera. These are all technological wonders, and using them means standing on the shoulders of giants.

It just looks different in physical construction.