News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by colemickens on Monday May 09, 2016 @10:29PM (#11664808)
Presumably these satellites are transmitting data back to Earth? Is that channel not bidirectional? If those satellites can be remote reprogrammed, are they really much different than satellites in geosynchronous orbit? Or are you suggesting that satellites in geosync orbit could be manually updated via EVA? I would think that would still be extremely cost-prohibitive (not to mention a huge risk to human life for a weather satellite! Has that ever actually happened?
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by walrus01 on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:31PM (#11664992)
I'm saying sort of the opposite - there have been very, very rare cases where satellites in LEO were visited by humans and repaired or retrieved, but it's extremely uneconomical (Hubble, LDEF, etc). Actually cheaper to build and launch a new one. But at least it is technologically possible. Whereas nobody has ever gone to geostationary orbit.

There have been proposals for ion engined orbital tugs to grab onto old, out-of-stationkeeping-propellant satellites that still have good electronics, for the purpose of extending their life, or moving them to a new orbital position. But nothing has actually flown.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by cmcginty on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:16AM (#11666127)
The moon is beyond geostationary orbit, and I think we've been there ;-)
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by ptaipale on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @08:12AM (#11666625)
Particularly, if you don't want to land on the Moon, just go round it and return, then it's easier - you don't need that much propulsion to get back.

But to get to geostationary orbit and stop there, you need rocket power. To get back, you would also need power.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by walrus01 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:47PM (#11669089)
We've been to the moon but humans have never put a manned craft in geostationary orbit, or returned from it - the delta-V requirements are different.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by misnome on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:30AM (#11666166)
Right, OP wasn't saying that we had never been _beyond_ GEO, but never been to the orbit - going through is a lot easier than stopping off partway.