News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linked list patent by anamax on Thursday March 04, 2010 @01:06AM (#1166299)
> Perhaps you can provide a counter example that shows the usefulness of software patents.

There are some interesting optimization methods that probably wouldn't have been made public if it weren't for patents.

I want all useful algorithms to become publically known. Patents help accomplish that.

How do you propose to get people to forego trade secret protection?

Re:Linked list patent by ssp on Thursday March 04, 2010 @02:22AM (#1166386)
There are some interesting optimization methods that probably wouldn't have been made public if it weren't for patents.

Which ones?

I want all useful algorithms to become publically known. Patents help accomplish that.

I don't think that's true. If you invent an algorithm that is genuinely novel and you get a competitive advantage from it, patenting it is the last thing you want to do. Keep it a trade secret.

Why? Because as a legitimate company you can't enforce the patent. If you try, you'll just be counter-sued for infringing someone else's patents.

Re:Linked list patent by fnid2 on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:04AM (#1166424)
PKZip was one that really moved the compression industry forward. JPEG is another. The current H.264 debate is a sound one and the owners of that patent have even publicly stated that it'll be free to use for the next 5 years or so. Imagine how many better methods may be discovered to compress and stream video than H.264 over the next half decade. That's a lot of time in this industry!
Re:Linked list patent by anamax on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:14PM (#1167393)
> There are some interesting optimization methods that probably wouldn't have been made public if it weren't for patents.

The one that I was thinking of was http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karmarkars_algorithm .

> If you invent an algorithm that is genuinely novel and you get a competitive advantage from it, patenting it is the last thing you want to do. Keep it a trade secret.

You're assuming that the competitive advantage from using the algorithm exceeds the value that one can get from licensing. That's not necessarily true.

> Because as a legitimate company you can't enforce the patent. If you try, you'll just be counter-sued for infringing someone else's patents.

That's not necessarily or always true. Take drugs - the majors don't clone one another - they honor each other's patents.