Ad blockers don't just block external ads, they use CSS rules to block internal ads as well. So the only way to avoid ad blockers is to make advertisement completely indistinguishable from content.
Imagine if Google did that, if they made sponsored results competent indistinguishable from organic results. The uproar would be loud.
reddit.com##.promotedlink
But Adblock Plus actually contains a second list of "Non-intrusive advertising" that actually allows ads on reddit. Many people are very angry about this list because many companies pay to get their ads put on it and allowed.Is this 100% verified, or just speculation? AB+ has always stated that they whitelist suitable ads, not ones that are paid. In my experience, this is true; only static text and image ads ever get through, and it's pretty rare. I think this is desirable as it incentivises the use of better ads.
In any case: I'll make sure that my ad blocker allows non intrusive ads. That said, "non intrusive" must not be deceptive either. It should be clear that it is an advert.
In response to ad blockers, sites install ad blocker blockers.
In response to ad blocker blockers, Reddit adds ad blocker blocker blocker.
I think in a war between ad's trying to assert a user has seen an ad, and clients trying to view content, so long as the client owns the computer, the client will win. That's why I hate walled gardens so much. I'm convinced it was a preemptive shot in this war.
Is Moore law against this?
A possible future scenario could be one were technology becomes so cheap that Apple/Google/Facebook .et all, starts "lending" their own hardware for free so people can access their _open_ walled-garden flavored internet.
Projects like of RPi/Arduino bring me hope that this wont ever happen, at least to us.
It's already at a point where I have to add Anti-Adblock Killer to prevent them from turning off ad blockers. Please don't ask to make it worse.
In response to add blocker blockers, ad blockers install ad blocker blocker blockers.
then onto your number 3
:)
it's an arms race!
This is like thinking that you would increase a crop yield by increasing the amount of fertilizer you put on it. There is an optimal balance beyond which you burn the crop with too much fertilizer.
I would suggest to significantly reduce the amount of advertisement on the site. Sell the add space with auction. Less advertisement increase the add efficiency. Increase the quality of content to increase the number of readers. Select high quality none intrusive adds that don't disrupt people's experience on the site.
In short take back the control of your site advertisement. Prohibit tricks your readers don't like (e.g. tracking), etc.
This is not much different from companies and hallmarks selling unhealthy food. The difference with adblocks is that people have a tool filtering out unhealthy food from their view. Who is the bad guy ? The client with its filter or the companies providing unhealthy food ?
Regulation doesn't work. We should know it by now. We have to take things in our own hand because the system is not able to keep a sane course by itself (cf. liberalism).
Given that Reddit is a large source of incoming referrals this stance (if implemented) might be a sufficient lever to send a signal to get those sites to improve their environment.
In any case since the sites are still able to use curated self hosted ads (ie not JavaScript redirects to externally hosted providers) they are able to sell static ad space to make money even with adblockers enabled.
It might be worth seeing what the outcome for the experiment is (if it goes ahead) and then seeing if the same logic would work for HN.