Re:Why You Can’t Lose Weight on a Diet
by dzhiurgis on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:38AM
(#11653774)
It could make sense, but author does not provide her height so most of the article is kind of a useless. BMI and especially total BF% for taller person is a good statistic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
She says she was in late 20's and 125 lbs. Even if she were 4 feet tall, she would be losing massive amounts of weight. Base metabolic rate at 5' tall is > 1200 calories/day.
The study of Biggest Loser contestants included people who (after they lost weight) were burning hundreds of calories LESS than a person of their weight normally would be. (The average metabolic deficit in the study was 500 calories/day; the largest metabolic deficit was 800 calories/day)
So no, it doesn't seem impossible for her testimony to be accurate at least approximately as given.