News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical Equipment Crashes During Heart Procedure Because ... by tremon on Saturday May 07, 2016 @03:45PM (#11651084)
Huh? Of course there is. "Familiar interface" isn't even a functional requirement, it is only of secondary importance for any system. Actual functionality is much more important.

As an aside, if "familiar interface" is your only requirement, I'd suggest to install a door handle or light switch.

Re:Medical Equipment Crashes During Heart Procedure Because ... by seanp2k2 on Saturday May 07, 2016 @04:22PM (#11651218)
Your comment may sound sarcastic on the first read, but I agree with the point; don't use Windows when what you needed could be done with a micro controller or a physical circuit. Not sure if the application here fits that at all, but I've definitely seen things like you-do-it check-outs, ATMs, billboards, etc running Windows. I would think that these systems would be much better off with something like a hardened micro controller running a remote display system vs a multi-gigabyte operating system.

With Windows 10, this problem will likely get a whole lot worse. What do you do when MS pushes a forced update to your deployed devices and it bricks some of them? http://m.theregister.co.uk/2016/05/06/microsoft_update_asus_...

What about when you can't disable Cortana (without breaking the start menu) and you're in a HIPAA / PCI environment? http://winaero.com/blog/how-to-uninstall-and-remove-cortana-...

As we've seen with things like SCADA, switching from Windows is not a silver bullet, but in terms of minimizing the complexity and attack surface, Windows seems to be starting at the opposite end of the spectrum.

Re:Medical Equipment Crashes During Heart Procedure Because ... by tremon on Saturday May 07, 2016 @06:13PM (#11651578)
Oh, I didn't even mean my comment to be about Windows vs dedicated OS, at least not directly. When administered correctly and properly fenced off, using a modern Windows system is not a cardinal sin. Although I will admit that Windows 10, with its non-optional feature cadence, brings additional uncertainty.

However, I do question "it looks like Windows" as a valid rationale for what appears to be a single-purpose machine. I don't think it's likely that staff are using the operating room equipment as a desktop machine, so presumably they only care about the in-app user interface. And an application interface can be made to "look like Windows" regardless of what OS it's running on.

Re:Medical Equipment Crashes During Heart Procedure Because ... by morgante on Sunday May 08, 2016 @11:12AM (#11654347)
Exactly.

If users are never meant to interact with the OS itself (airport terminals, ATMs, displays, etc.) then it makes absolutely no sense to use Windows.

Re:Medical Equipment Crashes During Heart Procedure Because ... by developer2 on Saturday May 07, 2016 @06:10PM (#11651564)
>> if "familiar interface" is your only requirement, I'd suggest to install a door handle or light switch

This isn't far from the truth. You'd be better of providing a console with clearly labelled buttons and switches. No operating system exposed to the user. It's not very practical to implement, let alone make changes to, but it would be more dummy proof than any desktop application.

This is also why you see a lot of kiosk-like, full-screen applications, with no ability to actually work with the desktop interface itself. A single kiosk application that cannot be alt-tabbed out of, providing screens that are easy to navigate.