Re:GiveDirectly Planning to Give $30M in Basic Income to Eas...
by nickff on Friday May 06, 2016 @04:43PM
(#11646604)
Bastiat's petition is well-enough known to be included in his (lengthy) Wikipedia entry.[1]
No, the parent is not "describing either the absolute or the comparative advantage of trade", because they said:
>"If Toms shoes dumps 1,000 pairs of shoes in the city center every week, how the hell would a cobbler stay in business."
and
>"[I]f the U.S. pumps an endless supply of rice into Haiti, how could Haitian rice farmers sell their inventory."
This is basic mercantilism, as described in the 'theory' section of the 'Mercantilism' Wikipedia entry, and more specifically the following points of the theory:
>"That every little bit of a country's soil be utilized for agriculture, mining or manufacturing.
...
That a large, working population be encouraged.
...
That all imports of foreign goods be discouraged as much as possible.
...
That no importation be allowed if such goods are sufficiently and suitably supplied at home."[2]
Cash is a better gift because you get to buy whatever you want, not because 'dumping' goods is bad.
No, the parent is not "describing either the absolute or the comparative advantage of trade", because they said:
>"If Toms shoes dumps 1,000 pairs of shoes in the city center every week, how the hell would a cobbler stay in business."
and
>"[I]f the U.S. pumps an endless supply of rice into Haiti, how could Haitian rice farmers sell their inventory."
This is basic mercantilism, as described in the 'theory' section of the 'Mercantilism' Wikipedia entry, and more specifically the following points of the theory:
>"That every little bit of a country's soil be utilized for agriculture, mining or manufacturing. ...
That a large, working population be encouraged. ...
That all imports of foreign goods be discouraged as much as possible. ...
That no importation be allowed if such goods are sufficiently and suitably supplied at home."[2]
Cash is a better gift because you get to buy whatever you want, not because 'dumping' goods is bad.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fr%C3%A9d%C3%A9ric_Bastiat#Eco...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercantilism#Theory