Re:Americans’ Distaste for Both Trump and Clinton Is Record-...
by herval on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:18AM
(#11643085)
Can you ellaborate on hypnosis being "total baloney"? I know trained hypnotists and seen it work first-hand, curious to see your evidence...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Americans’ Distaste for Both Trump and Clinton Is Record-...
by bad_user on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:27AM
(#11643135)
The kind of hypnosis you see in movies is "baloney", people know what hypnosis is from movies, hence this impression.
Re:Americans’ Distaste for Both Trump and Clinton Is Record-...
by rantanplan on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:50AM
(#11643253)
I don't know what people know from movies, but personally I've researched hypnosis.
And as with all other evidence around it, I agree that the "altered state of mind" part is total baloney.
If you have evidence to the contrary please share, thanks.
Re:Americans’ Distaste for Both Trump and Clinton Is Record-...
by rantanplan on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:23AM
(#11643114)
Um... curious to see your evidence. I've "hypnotized" people too. Everyone can "hypnotize" some people. All evidence goes against any kind of altered state of mind though. More like submissive role-playing.
Also, for future reference, things that should make your alarm bells go off:
a) something works on someone only when you describe it to that someone
b) something works only on some people, not all of them and you don't know why.
EDIT: some people didn't understand that what I'm implying with the above points is that hypnosis is more akin to the placebo effect than anything else(altered state of mind etc).
Re:Americans’ Distaste for Both Trump and Clinton Is Record-...
by herval on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:32AM
(#11643159)
So basically most medicine is "baloney" for you too? (see: placebo effect and many different drugs that won't work on everyone)
Re:Americans’ Distaste for Both Trump and Clinton Is Record-...
by rantanplan on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:40AM
(#11643198)
Of course not!
But no hypnotist says that hypnosis is placebo!!!
I totally agree that it is.