Re:Introducing a new, advanced Visual C++ code optimizer
by gratilup on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:42AM
(#11643206)
That's why that patterns is not applied in the new optimizer, unless the Bit Estimator proves x+1 does not overflow. After it was implemented to behave like what other compilers do, I analyzed several applications and libraries and it would have introduced silent security problems - I explained in the blog post.
For example most CPUs wrap from most positive to most negative on integer overflow, but one kind might just clamp the value at the most positive value. Or give an error, so forcing them to behave in a given way would make it hard to write efficient C programs on some platforms.
Recently some compiler writers decided that they could interpret undefined behavior to mean "Do anything we like".
So for example a sane compiler on x86-64 would compile this :-
into a code which adds one to a variable then compared it with the original, and this absolutely can return both false and true. However compiler writers have gone Aha! Overflow is undefined, so we'll "optimize" this into always returning false. That is faster code, who wouldn't want faster code!Personally I think this was never the intent of the standard and compiler writers are abusing the meaning of undefined in order to sneak in optimizations but realy they are just producing compilers that are less and less trustworthy as they no longer do that people want or need.