Re:The curious case of slow downloads
by Animats on Thursday May 05, 2016 @02:11AM
(#11634289)
They just rediscovered silly window syndrome, but at the application level rather than the TCP level.
In early TCP implementations, if you read from a TCP connection one byte at a time, and the sender was writing faster than the receiver, the sender TCP would get an ACK opening one byte of window. The sender TCP would then transmit a packet with only one byte. This often came up if a TCP connection was driving a slow device. The fix was to not send a window update until there was at least one full packet worth of window available.
This is the same problem, but at the OS buffering level. Linux has a similar solution. The problem is 1) servers today have to protect themselves against readers that are "too slow", because that can be used as a denial of service attack, and 2) the approach to doing this was not well designed.
This is a tough one for Cloudflare, because they're in the DDOS-prevention business. They have to decide whether a slow reader is an attacker or just someone on a slow connection. Still, insisting that a reader consume at least 5MB/minute is a bit much. Some people are still on dialup.
In early TCP implementations, if you read from a TCP connection one byte at a time, and the sender was writing faster than the receiver, the sender TCP would get an ACK opening one byte of window. The sender TCP would then transmit a packet with only one byte. This often came up if a TCP connection was driving a slow device. The fix was to not send a window update until there was at least one full packet worth of window available.
This is the same problem, but at the OS buffering level. Linux has a similar solution. The problem is 1) servers today have to protect themselves against readers that are "too slow", because that can be used as a denial of service attack, and 2) the approach to doing this was not well designed.
This is a tough one for Cloudflare, because they're in the DDOS-prevention business. They have to decide whether a slow reader is an attacker or just someone on a slow connection. Still, insisting that a reader consume at least 5MB/minute is a bit much. Some people are still on dialup.