News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by wskinner on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:33PM (#11629999)
That seems like it would raise a serious issue of moral hazard.
Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:39PM (#11630060)
Not if you pull the license of repeat offenders. F* up once? It happens, medicine is hard (EDIT: Document what went wrong, put a process in place so it doesn't happen again, issue a notice to all other medical facilities offering related procedures). F* up again? You're out of a job.

No different then how the FAA and the NTSB operate.

EDIT: Medicine can be made safer through the same processes used to ensure air travel is the safest transport method in the world. It can't be as safe, but we can do better.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by rplst8 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:54PM (#11630199)
I disagree entirely. People are known to be fallible. Processes prevent things from accidentally happening. In areas where the life of someone or a large organizational failure hangs in the balance of an action, that action should be wrapped in process to ensure it's correct execution, with fail-safe mechanisms put in place.

Further, these systems should be audited on a regular basis to ensure compliance.

Only in the case of purposeful or willful action or absolute gross negligence or being found unfit for duty (mentally or physically) should someone have their life ruined by removing their status/job/career path.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by DanBC on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:13PM (#11633006)
> Only in the case of purposeful or willful action or absolute gross negligence or being found unfit for duty (mentally or physically) should someone have their life ruined by removing their status/job/career path.

Yes, and that "loss of job" or professional de-registration means many doctors do not seek help for mental illness. That might be one reason the suicide rate in doctors is so high. (Knowledge of effective methods; access to means and methods; and work stress are other reasons).

In the UK Louis Appleby (who does a lot around suicide prevention in England) is doing some work with the General Medical Council (one of the regulators of doctors) around suicide prevention for doctors who are being investigated by GMC during fitness to practice. http://www.gmc-uk.org/Suicide_review___Final_Draft_Proposals...

It also means doctors are more risky for patients. We need a way for doctors to seek help that protects them and their patients.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by ryanlol on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @04:13PM (#11631354)
>Only in the case of purposeful or willful action or absolute gross negligence or being found unfit for duty (mentally or physically) should someone have their life ruined by removing their status/job/career path.

Seriously? Losing your job hardly means that your life is ruined.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by thebokehwokeh2 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:54PM (#11632630)
More than any other occupation, doctors spend a majority of their young adult lives learning about medicine and everything related to it. By removing them of their license to practice that, you've essentially stripped them of their life's purpose.
Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by neurotech1 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:23PM (#11633548)
They could still work as a research physician, or work for medical device manufacturer or drug company.

If they are really bad at clinical practice, they might get a job on a TV show. Psychologist Dr Phil McGraw [0] stopped practicing after an investigation, and ended up as a talk show host.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil_McGraw

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by ryanlol on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:35PM (#11633117)
I don't think any of the doctors I've met would consider medicine their life's purpose.

Most people seem to have much more mundane goals.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by jleader on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:04PM (#11631782)
So you're advocating forgiving the educational loans of doctors who lose their license? Or do you leave them massively in debt, without the (relatively) lucrative profession they had assumed would allow them to pay off that debt?
Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:19PM (#11632763)
> So you're advocating forgiving the educational loans of doctors who lose their license?

Yes, although the better solution is to subsidize the education of medical providers directly, instead of burdening them with massive loans that take decades to repay. That's an argument for another thread though.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by ryanlol on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:44PM (#11632551)
I'm not advocating anything.

I'm just saying that losing your job/career/whatever doesn't equal a ruined life.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by maxxxxx on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:44PM (#11630111)
Everybody makes serious errors from time to time. At least me and everybody I know. You should be able to admit them without losing your career or being ruined. Obviously if somebody makes a lot more errors than others he should lose his job.

My point is that the current system encourages denial and cover up. It doesn't encourage improvement.

Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by lmm on Thursday May 05, 2016 @03:52AM (#11634568)
I don't think anyone wants to kill their patients. So what's the adverse scenario here? Doctors being paid per-operation and skipping safety steps? Doctors wanting to make a name for themselves and taking on ambitious surgeries that shouldn't be done? It seems like you could cover those cases without making individual doctors massively liable for essentially random mistakes.
Re:Medical error is third biggest cause of death in the US, ... by wskinner on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @01:41PM (#11630081)
I would describe being fired if you f* up again as being held liable. Liability doesn't have to be monetary.