Re:Very Short But Amazing Speech by Coca Cola CEO Bryan Dyson
by joe_the_user on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @07:06PM
(#1162938)
An Ad hominem attack is an attack which cites an irrelevant quality of a person to discredit them. Citing a relevant behavior of someone is well within acceptable discourse.
Suppose a famous scientist is exposed as having faked a well-know result. Does that make you go back and look at his or her other results? Well, yes.
Someone tells you to put health first while selling a product widely disparaged as destroying people health? Relevant, I'd believe so.
Re:Very Short But Amazing Speech by Coca Cola CEO Bryan Dyson
by dbz on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @12:52AM
(#1163513)
This person was telling people to spend time with family. The fact that he is the CEO of coke which may or may not be healthy is completely irrelevant.
Suppose a famous scientist is exposed as having faked a well-know result. Does that make you go back and look at his or her other results? Well, yes.
Someone tells you to put health first while selling a product widely disparaged as destroying people health? Relevant, I'd believe so.