News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:20PM (#11623446)
Most proposals I've seen include progressive tax, and usually an increase in progressivity. Also, some proposals are simply no change to funding, with the UBI directly using the funds of other benefit programs that it replaces.

A flat tax (or even just a decrease in progressivity) directly works against the purpose of adopting a UBI.

EDIT: Changed "all" to "most"; I've definitely seen right-wing proponents advocating varieties of UBI + Flat Tax schemes and UBI + National Sales Tax schemes, which are not funded by progressive taxes; also added the note about no-new-funding programs.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by dllthomas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:33PM (#11623997)
To clarify, most proposals I've seen have involved one of the roughly equivalent options of a separate flat tax specifically to fund UBI or an increase of the same amount across all tax brackets.

I have seen some proposals involving replacement of taxation generally with a flat tax coupled with a UBI - sold specifically as being able to still produce an overall progressive curve with the simplicity of a flat tax. While I think those are both positive things, I find this oversold - most of the complexity of taxation has little to do with brackets, and while the resulting curve is progressive it is only a particular family of curves and it's plenty possible that the optimal curves (by whatever metrics we assign) are not in that family.

I have seen some proposals that involve a progressive increase in taxation; these have been (in my recollection) fewer and less detailed than the first category - mostly, I expect, because they are a bit harder to analyze.