News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by jwr on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @04:49AM (#1160989)
Why do people downmod Jason's post? Disagreeing is not a reason for downmodding. I was interested in his response, whatever it might be. I want to judge for myself.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by demallien on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @05:00AM (#1161003)
Because the post is positively oozing insincerity, and most of us here value honesty?
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by dschobel on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @12:47PM (#1161994)
Except his posts all get a reflexive down-vote to -4. I don't see the point, obviously the discussion here is better for his defending himself.

Give the guy some credit for showing up in front of the firing squad and trying to defend himself.

Or we can turn this into a complete echo chamber where we can all bad-mouth Jason in absentia.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by krtl on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @05:12PM (#1162713)
I guess people feel like he doesn't deserve credit.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by swombat on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @06:15AM (#1161108)
Irrelevant. That's not what voting is for. I've upvoted every one of Jason's posts, not because I agree with them, but because downvoting is for something else.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by bad_user on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @07:41AM (#1161209)
It's not for you to decide what down-voting is for.

Some people don't like lies, other people don't like off-topic posts, other people don't like fallacies, and other people just don't have time to write a disagreement post ... especially if the assertions made in the down-voted comment aren't worth bothering with.

And if down-voting should have a purpose ... then it should definitely be for filtering out people not in HN's demographic.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by jon_dahl on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @01:54PM (#1162174)
And if down-voting should have a purpose ... then it should definitely be for filtering out people not in HN's demographic.

That might be true for people who want to use HN to talk about politics or religion, but Jason is definitely in our demographic. He's a web startup founder, whether or not his startup sucks.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by whyleyc on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @06:48AM (#1161148)
What do you consider grounds for a down-vote then ? (this is sincere question)
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by swombat on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @07:54AM (#1161230)
Two possibilities:

1) In the case of obvious trolling or idiocy, e.g. "lol your mom sucks" or "ur dumb", downvoting below zero is warranted because those comments are stuff that we don't want to see at all.

2) In the case of everything else, downvoting is warranted, imho, only when something has been upvoted beyond where it should be. For example, if Jason's posts were at 50 upvotes, I would downvote them, because that's totally unwarranted. In this case, I'd downvote them even at 10 points... they're relevant because of who he is and how he's connected to this, but not that insightful.

Basically, for all non-troll posts, you should upvote/downvote based on whether you feel the post has the points it deserves, and generally never downvote below zero.

In this case, Jason, although controversial, is not an obvious stupid troll - he's responding to points that people are making. I would like to see his posts somewhere between 1 and 5 points, rather than at -4.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by jon_dahl on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @01:48PM (#1162162)
I look at HN voting in the same way. If you upvote what you agree with and downvote what you don't, you end up with Reddit, where "lolz your mom" gets +12 and reasoned disagreement ends up -30.

I actually end up upvoting a lot of <1 point comments, even ones I disagree with. If the comment is reasonably coherent and not trolling, it usually shouldn't be below 1.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by whyleyc on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @11:20AM (#1161731)
Thanks for the explanation of how you decide.

I guess since there are no explicit references in the HN guidelines it's up to each user to make his or her mind up themselves.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by awa on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @02:13PM (#1162232)
I was also interested in his replies, but it seems he has a different answer ready for the HN crowd and different one for the world as pointed by his tweets linked by jfarmer.

For me, changing a statement like this is pretty close to lying and is probably worse than trolling.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by twinwing on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @09:19AM (#1161395)
I just had a 40 minute bike shed moment thanks to this question.

How else would you indicate strong disagreement with a comment given the HN culture of well thought out replies and a zero cost binary device for weighing in on an issue, when you have nothing else to contribute other than "I disagree"/"I do not like your post"?

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by neilk on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:55AM (#1163895)
Upvote the commenter who makes the point you wanted to make. If no one else says it, you say it.

For instance, I upvoted Calcanis' comment (to rescue it from negative number territory) and upvoted the people who pointed out the insincerity / inconsistency. Both kinds of posts advanced the general knowledge.

I didn't have to upvote the more personal attacks on Calcanis. But it did feel pretty good. ;)

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by ohashi on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @04:58AM (#1161000)
I think people judged with their votes.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by krtl on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @05:11PM (#1162706)
Then you should judge and upvote his post. Please do not tell people how to vote -- that itself is judging. Users are given the ability to upvote or downvote and the community should see that through. Its always interesting to me how many people jump in and try to establish rules on upvoting and downvoting. I'm sorry but every member of this community should upvote and downvote as they please.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by poutine on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @10:35AM (#1161598)
Agreed, regardless of whether you disagree with him or not, his post is quite topical to this article.
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by jasonmcalacanis on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @05:07AM (#1161012)
because they are Jason Haters.... Jayters.

there are a group of them who down vote everything i post... doesn't matter how insightful... TEN DOWN VOTES!!

it's kind of funny.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by niyazpk on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @05:50AM (#1161069)
I did not downvote your comment even though your comment sounded insincere and provocative. I did not down-vote because it was already low on points. I think most HN-ers hate downvoting.

there are a group of them who down vote everything i post... doesn't matter how insightful...

I don't have much experience in the industry other than reading a few blogs and even I could not spot any insights in most of your past comments in HN (especially the ones from the SEOmoz debate).

Anyway, I've got more important things to attend to at 1AM than Daniel extortion plot fall out.

Really? This is enough to piss off anyone who read it. As far as I can understand you forwarded a private email. You have more important things to do than attending to things you screwed up? I can't understand what is so insightful in that.

(Good that you apologized to Daniel. Kudos)

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by jasonmcalacanis on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @06:02AM (#1161084)
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by die_sekte on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @05:15AM (#1161029)
"Hey! There is nothing wrong with what I do or what I say! It's those bad haters!"
Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by whyleyc on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @06:44AM (#1161141)
"Resist complaining about being downmodded. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading."

From http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by almost on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @12:18PM (#1161912)
I'm not sure that's it. I've down voted some of your comments because they just seem to ooze insensibility and really have you coming across like an almighty bell-end. I don't know you apart from a few comments of yours I've seen here on HN.

Just a simple apology would probably have been your best bet. Everyone makes mistakes. Best not to lash out at the people you've already harmed.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by awa on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @03:53PM (#1162485)
http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=jasonmcalacanis

If you look at your comment history, this is not true. Some people are down voting you extensively in this thread, this is not true for the whole community or even for your comments outside this thread.

Re:I was the one who came forward about the Macbook Air by samd on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @09:43AM (#1161441)
All the downvoting actually makes finding and reading your comments in a post a lot easier. Just look for the faded blocks of text in the sea of dark letters.