Without getting into semantics, Moore's Law roughly assumes that things will get cheaper or you'll get significantly greater bang for your buck. "Nobody said it would be easy" is a casual dismissal of the fact that consumers won't pay for this, unless someone conjures a materials revolution.
And no, we can't just assume the head of Intel will conjure up a materials revolution solely to adhere to an industry observational law.
Re:10nm versus 7nm
by logicallee on Sunday May 01, 2016 @10:42PM
(#11608930)
I don't know, man:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore's_law#Moore.27s_second_l...
This talks about an exponential increase in R&D costs which is expected by Moore. With stuff like cloud computing, I don't see the need for denser and denser CPU's going away any time soon.
Haven't you answered your own question? Your other points are about impossibility - the one I just quoted, about making chips taller, is about difficulty.
If I were the head of Intel I would say "Well. Hmmm. All right. I guess we'd better start making them taller."
Moore's law is not a question of "how hard can it be". As you've pointed out, on the current approach it's a question of "It is physically impossible for us to increase transistor count without dropping the clock rate or moving out of roughly a plane. No thanks to Einstein. (My favorite link on this subject: https://www.google.com/search?q=c+%2F+4+ghz )
You say "Or make them taller, but then you can't cool them easily." Well then, make them taller and cool them with difficulty. Nobody said it would be easy. Off-hand you could:
-> Immerse the taller chip in insane cooling
-> Fabricate little duct work between layers and liquid cool at high velocity
-> Figure out a way to reduce heat waste usage, e.g.: different substrate, not silicon (pretty insane)
-> Possibly combining some of the above points, make it a superconductor.
These are insane ideas from me. But then again, I'm not the head of Intel and you've heard a few minutes of thought on me on this topic, where I'm not a chip designer.
"When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however [difficult], is your [roadmap.]"