Re:US surveillance court reportedly rejected zero spying req...
by rhino369 on Sunday May 01, 2016 @02:28PM
(#11607279)
Plus they are federal judges. Even if they could be fired (I see no mechanism for that), they are still federal district court judges for life.
Re:US surveillance court reportedly rejected zero spying req...
by awinter-py on Sunday May 01, 2016 @02:48PM
(#11607364)
The judges take turns in one week duty cycles (http://fas.org/irp/news/2013/07/fisc-leahy.pdf). One can assume DOJ is smart enough to avoid the judge who says no.
Page 8 of the PDF is worth a read. The head judge of the FISC is claiming that non-government entities have the opportunity to be heard by the court because they can (1) refuse a court order which (2) triggers a contempt hearing if (3) the DOJ permits it.
Re:US surveillance court reportedly rejected zero spying req...
by schoen on Monday May 02, 2016 @06:21PM
(#11616189)
> One can assume DOJ is smart enough to avoid the judge who says no.
I can imagine that that happens to some extent, but it's quite a bit weaker than what you originally suggested (and maybe there are other factors that prevent or deter the applicants from exercising complete control over who reviews their applications).
Re:US surveillance court reportedly rejected zero spying req...
by awinter-py on Monday May 02, 2016 @08:00PM
(#11616816)
Hmm, maybe. Given the court's secrecy and the general tendency of judges to defer to law enforcement on what constitutes an emergency, I assume there are cases where the gov't acts first and gets permission afterwards. If that's the case (and I recognize it's an if), and if every request is approved by the weak-willed judges (history suggests yes), then they have complete freedom to choose their judge.
Any indication that judges have ever been "fired" from the FISA Court?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intellig...