Re:The A-10 Warthog May Be Kept Out of Retirement by Law
by 55acdda48ab5 on Saturday April 30, 2016 @11:15AM
(#11601999)
> "stop doing COIN in poor countries" is a political solution that requires a top-down policy change
Yeah? That was my whole point. You make it sound like it's crazy. It's the most sensible course.
Re:The A-10 Warthog May Be Kept Out of Retirement by Law
by cstross on Saturday April 30, 2016 @01:12PM
(#11602514)
In the abstract, yes, it's the most sensible course. Unfortunately, from where I'm watching (hint: not an American) it looks like the State Department has an ad-hoc de-facto promotion track whereby you can't make it to the top unless you've got a proven record of running a short, victorious war. Not that this is official policy or anything so formally clear-cut -- it's more like an emergent property of the institution itself, and the priorities that the bureaucracy has evolved to service -- but you don't get to become SecState unless you're a hawk and the best way to acquire hawk credentials is to "pick up some small crappy little country and throw it against the wall, just to show the world we mean business" as Michael Ledeen put it (according to Jonah Goldberg).
(Tertiary source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Ledeen )
Or not to get into wars in the first place; then you could give up having an Air Force at all, right?
Seriously, "stop doing COIN in poor countries" is a political solution that requires a top-down policy change that goes counter to the entire historical direction of US military involvement since Vietnam. The US very seldom tackles even a second-rate military armed with Russian cast-offs -- the most recent example was Iraq in 2003 -- so the A-10 is still useful for the sort of brushfire wars and missions you get involved with. Even though they'd die like flies in a shooting war with a real front-rank opponent. (Like who?)