News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by xsmasher on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:27PM (#1160124)
No, claiming that the earthquake damage stimulates the economy would be the broken window fallacy. Aside from being a simple safety measure, building codes are more like insurance - you're making this investment in a building, let's spend a little more money to make sure it's going to survive fire, flood, and quakes. Same with safety standards on cars.

Insurance is always a gamble; if you buy it and never use it, you lose. If you don't buy it and later need it, you lose. This assumes you have the money for the insurance of course; Haiti did not have the money for insurance or seat-belts, and got thrown from the car into a concrete pylon.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by camccann on Monday March 01, 2010 @07:41PM (#1160291)
Claiming that the stricter building codes would stimulate the economy is arguably also the same fallacy, just without the obvious net-negative of the "broken window" case.

On the other hand, even disregarding the risk mitigation, it's also arguable that the seemingly burdensome building codes would inflict no appreciable harm on the economy, for exactly the same reasons that the broken window fallacy sounds plausible.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by xsmasher on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @01:58AM (#1160789)
Agreed that if no disaster occurs then the building code is just moving money around from one industry to another, with no net benefit.

If disaster does occur than the code has prevented the destruction of capital, and therefore has benefited the economy -- maybe not "stimulated", but benefited by preventing a greater loss.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by cynicalkane on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @09:32AM (#1161418)
Preventing the windows from being broken isn't the broken window fallacy.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Monday March 01, 2010 @07:18PM (#1160234)
Mm, the logic here is ultimately of economic activity for the sake of activity; that the activity is useful is a happy accident. It is different from the broken window fallacy, but not greatly.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by brazzy on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:36PM (#1160152)
if you buy it and never use it, you lose. If you don't buy it and later need it, you lose.

The point being: you can afford the first loss, and cannot afford the second one. If the second half is not true, you have identified an insurance policy you don't need.