News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:11PM (#1160080)
Municipalities would miss out on a lot of traffic ticket money if laws made people wear seatbelts; not the best example.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by brazzy on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:25PM (#1160111)
Actually it's a perfect example. That people still won't wear the seatbelt when they're not just running a small risk to lose their life, but additionally a not quite as small risk to pay a fine shows that people suck at dealing with risks - or maybe that they're careless and forgetful, but designing a building isn't the kind of thing where you just forget an important step (ín part because it's feasible to inspect every single building for compliance, as opposed to inspecting every single auto driver and passenger).
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:31PM (#1160139)
"designing a building isn't the kind of thing where you just forget an important step"

Nor is having a building built much like getting into a car and "forgetting" to put on a seatbelt. If anything, I think your point makes the example less relevant.

"ín part because it's feasible to inspect every single building for compliance"

Absent corruption of the inspection process. Turkey had building codes and many wrecked buildings after the last major earthquake that had "passed" inspection due to money changing hands under the table.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by brazzy on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:42PM (#1160161)
No, it is your example that is made less relevant.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Monday March 01, 2010 @07:03PM (#1160208)
The only example here is yours - I didn't bring up seatbelts.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by brazzy on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @01:58AM (#1160788)
You brought up people not wearing seatbelts despite laws, apparently implying that building codes would not be followed as well.

This point is invalidated by my observation because with seat-belt laws, the entity passing the law cannot realistically inspect compliance in every case while with building codes, it can.

Additionally, while seat-belt laws have not achieved 100% compliance, they have raised rates of seat-belt use from from 11% in 1981 to 68% in 1997

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @12:28PM (#1161941)
"You brought up people not wearing seatbelts despite laws, apparently implying that building codes would not be followed as well."

I pointed out that seatbelts were a bad example for your argument. All you've done is emphasize that seatbelts are a bad example that don't fit what you're trying to say about building codes.

As as per the Turkey example, one would hope you're willing to acknowledge that even with the ability to inspect every structure, such factors as corruption, poor inspectors, bad inspection practices, plain human error, etc. mean that the we cannot assume universal compliance.

As important as building codes are, there are factors entirely separate from the codes themselves that determine how well they're actually followed.

"while seat-belt laws have not achieved 100% compliance, they have raised rates of seat-belt use"

I'm afraid you can't firmly demonstrate that relationship; 1981-1997 was also a period of extremely heavy propagandizing to get people to wear seatbelts.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by lmkg on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:24PM (#1160110)
The legislation requiring automobiles to include seat belts[1] was passed at the federal level, not at the municipal level. At the municipal level, resources are also put into seat belt education campaigns and PSAs, which if effective would lower the availability of scofflaws as a potential revenue source. So yes, it's still a valid example.

(I assume you meant type type "if laws didn't make people..." or equivalent)

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Traffic_and_Motor_Vehi...

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:26PM (#1160118)
"I assume you meant type type "if laws didn't make people..." or equivalent"

How would that even make sense?

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by lmkg on Monday March 01, 2010 @09:26PM (#1160434)
Your original comment:

> "Municipalities would miss out on a lot of traffic ticket money if laws made people wear seatbelts; not the best example."

I thought that the original sentiment you meant to express was that municipalities have an economic incentive to create seatbelt laws, in order to fine people who break them, with the implication being that seat belt laws are made for selfish reasons, not reasons related to the public well-being. I parsed the sentence, as written, as saying that the presence of an additional fine-worthy offense would somehow lower the amount of fine-generated revenue, and inferred the mistaken absence of a negation. After scrutinizing your comment and follow-up for some time, it's possible to parse the sentence as saying that if seatbelt laws were more effective at making people wear seat belts, this would reduce revenue. This sentence, while correct, does not seem more than tangentially related in context of replying to the parent. Perhaps you can clarify if I'm missing something.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Monday March 01, 2010 @09:31PM (#1160442)
I'll put it simply: if seatbelt laws made people wear seatbelts, municipalities would not be able to collect revenue by ticketing people for not wearing seatbelts.
Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by brazzy on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @02:04AM (#1160793)
And if the penal code made people not kill and rob and steal, prisons would be empty?

Compliance to laws is not an all-or-nothing thing, and the statistics clearly show a massive increase in compliance after the enactment of seat-belt laws.

Re:The Power of Building Codes: Chile Death Toll Less Than 1... by Semiapies on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @12:34PM (#1161955)
"And if the penal code made people not kill and rob and steal, prisons would be empty?"

Let me know when someone gets convicted of a seatbelt violation after the extensive use of forensic evidence, victim testimony, and a statewide manhunt.

Let me know when a police officer sweats a confession out of someone that ey didn't wear a seatbelt.

Let me know when police offer a reward for information leading to the conviction of someone who failed to wear a seatbelt.

At that point, your apples will then become oranges.