News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by falcolas on Friday April 29, 2016 @01:22PM (#11597202)
I'm regretting commenting now. Like a bikeshed next to a nuclear plant, anybody who has ever lost any amount of weight has an opinion on how it's done.

Reducing fat reduces caloric intake. Note the word reduce (I even emphasized it), instead of remove, or replace. Yes, fats are a healthy part of a good diet. No, you should not omit them.

Of course, don't take my word for it. RTFOP, which made the recommendation in the first place.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by alexc05 on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:17PM (#11598087)
> Reducing fat reduces caloric intake.

Indeed, but people who want to "lose weight" actually don't care how heavy they are, they care how they look and want "to be slimmer" which is the actual result we're trying for while colloquially using the term "lose weight" to describe that effect.

(this is of course a sweeping over-generalization where there are actually a number of other reasons, related to health, fatty liver etc...)

With a goal of "BEING SLIMMER" we're actually more interested in draining triglycerides from our fat cells so they shrink. (after that we can induce apoptosis and kill them off via freezing but that's another story).

Since the goal is to drain fat cells, we're actually better served by keeping our bodies in the state where they are "emptying the fuel tanks (stored fat)" as opposed to "burning the cheap stuff (carbohydrates)"

By reducing CARB intake we can keep the fat-cells open and draining. BUT in order to reduce carb intake, we have to replace it with a macronutrient which will induce satiety.

Dietary fat is that macronutrient.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by athenot on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:10PM (#11597568)
From a metabolic point of view, that is correct. What others are trying to point out is there is a mental aspect to that, involving our appetite feedback loop. The human body is a highly interdependent system, not a set of isolated microservices.

The way I view it is to maximize the enjoyment out of food. Don't just view it as fuel to be ingested as fast as possible; savor it! Appreciate the flavor of that rice, that bacon. It may sound like becoming a food snob—which it can if one has elitist tentencies—but it's more about appreciating the components that make up the food we eat, and turning it into an art.

An implied requirement for that is to slow down and take the time to eat. There's about a 20m delay for the feedback loop of satiation to occur. So eating slowly and in courses gives our bodies the time to appreciate what is coming in and for the mechanisms to provide better feedback. I'm always amazed at how some can ingest a 1800 kcal meal in 15 minutes: no feedback can happen that fast.

(Disclaimer: yes I'm French)

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by e40 on Friday April 29, 2016 @01:26PM (#11597238)
Reducing fat reduces caloric intake.

Looks like you're doubling down. Your statement is 100% correct. The problem is, fat calories are more satisfying than non-fat calories, so you are more likely to eat less if you eat protein + fat instead of protein + carbs + less fat. That's just the wait it works.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by rm_-rf_slash on Friday April 29, 2016 @01:37PM (#11597313)
One should eat less fat and carbs, but in doing so one will be less satisfied and be more likely to snack or eat larger portions later, negating the effect.

The problem is that while I am a good and level-headed person, my future self is a hungry bastard.