News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Infosec's Jerk Problem (2013) by vox_mollis on Friday April 29, 2016 @12:10PM (#11596639)
I can think of several people who fit firmly into both. Moxie, for instance. I fail to see how these two categories are mutually exclusive.
Re:Infosec's Jerk Problem (2013) by tptacek on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:03PM (#11597508)
Hold on. The definition of my #1 category isn't a belief in good and evil; it's the idea that their primary function in the field is to save the world, not to perfect security engineering. Looking at Moxie's work, I don't think anyone can legitimately accuse him of not taking engineering seriously.
Re:Infosec's Jerk Problem (2013) by vox_mollis on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:15PM (#11597612)
I understand that, but it's reasonable to suspect that for a significant number of #2s, #1 is the initial motivating factor that got them learning.

We see this all the time in software development, where excellent engineers are borne of trying to build a video game at age x, where x is a relatively low number.

Similarly, there's no reason that someone initially motivated to eradicate "evil" can't become a great security mind, and I suspect Moxie and many like him are of this ilk.

Re:Infosec's Jerk Problem (2013) by tptacek on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:17PM (#11597627)
Again: you're rebutting me as if my argument was that anyone who believed in "good" and "evil" was a #1. That's not my definition of a #1.