Less of an insult than some may think. There are significant signals buried beneath the huge noise at 4chan
Most of ZH's reporting is backed by numbers coming from other sources. They also report rumors ahead of everyone else, which seem implausible, but later turn out to be facts and reported by other outlets.
Yes, they have topic selection bias, but so does everyone else.
>They also report rumors ahead of everyone else, which seem implausible, but later turn out to be facts ...
Sure, if you spitting out rumors all day there will be one or two cases per year where you hit a nail.
Seriously, they do. They spin them in weird ways, though - I remember in 2007 (or early 2008), they had an article about "the bin laden trade" - someone bet $30M or so on a very improbably collapse -- Or so the article inferred based on highly irregular "put" purchase -- losing $30M if that didn't happen, or winning billions if it did.
The data was, in fact, factual. However, they failed to account for alternative explanations, e.g. that someone (probably a pension fund or a hedge fund) was moving a lot of money into the market, and was buying insurance -- a much more likely explanation for the same data.
They do stick to facts. It's their analysis that you should reserve your skepticism to.
1. The government releases a report with an important indicator looking good
2. Mainstream Media cheers, telling us how good we have it
3. ZH looks at the report and notices that:
- the number was "seasonally adjusted" once, then again
- the number will be revised down, a month later usually on a late Friday at happy hour
- pesky details: employment growth is in part-time, minimum-wage jobs
ZH often reports facts from official government reports/documents - they are typically buried on page 99 out of 100 (for a reason).Some people may choose to call the above rumors or "sensationalism" - feel free to ignore ZH, it is a free country.
In The Past Year, The U.S. Added 360,000 Waiters And Only 12,000 Manufacturing Workers
(not sure this is an example of what you were looking for)
No question about the color, but do you have an example for those "break on important stories".
For example, this post on Trump's nomination chances [1] draws heavily upon charts produced by Goldman Sachs, presumably for their clients only.
[1] http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-03-20/can-trump-win-gener...
Edited to add: I also know this because a friend of mine had their report leaked and written about on ZH, leading to a bit of a storm in a teacup at their workplace.
But yes, those leaked reports on ZH are interesting. Problem is they also publish lots of stuff from disputable sources. At the end you don't know what to take serious on this website, which results in an entropy of about zero.
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-09-26/coming-soon-theater...
Believe it or not it has a huge following in the finance world due to it often being one of the first ones to break or provide color on important stories.
It's not uncommon at all to see a row of traders with tweet deck open allocating a single column to Zero hedge, they are just that prolific with their output.
The downside of the site is that they tend to have a very big bearish slant though. No one has ever accused them of being neutral.
I hope they continue to run the site. I find it provides a fair bit of value to me.