News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by huherto on Monday March 01, 2010 @10:25AM (#1158860)
"I was not a loser, but I just wanted to live ordinarily" Perhaps this is the best proof of his extraordinary intelligence.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by jraynor on Monday March 01, 2010 @02:44PM (#1159559)
I would be very interested in reading comments elaborating on this stance by people that agree with it, since my view is a bit different.

In the interest of human progress, I would prefer that people with great ability are encouraged by society and their peers (which I assume the great minds at HN are likely to be among). I mean this in terms of what I see should be encouraged and done so through morals and not laws (e.g. in no way promote the violation of a person's freedom or liberty).

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by metamemetics on Monday March 01, 2010 @05:32PM (#1159981)
Having a high IQ can be as much of a curse as it is a blessing. Sometimes the pressure is too much and you want to try and stop thinking and just observe.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by wisty on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:02PM (#1160051)
I have quite a high IQ. When I was starting school, they though I had a learning disability. My parents sent me to be tested . Apparently I was one of the smartest kids that the tester had seen, but I was a bit disorganized and tended to overfocus (which would be diagnosed as mild ADHD these days ... when everyone has to have a frigging disorder). I don't know how high the score was, or how many kids he had tested, or whether all the other kids were genuinely low IQ ... who care about this stuff anyway?

My parents were smart enough to not tell me (until I was halfway through uni), because they knew I wasn't mature enough to know that the smartest thing you can do (especially when you are learning) is giving other people's intelligence the benefit of the doubt and try to learn from them.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by kls on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @06:38AM (#1161137)
--I would prefer that people with great ability are encouraged by society and their peers

While in concept it is a great idea, the realities are usually much harder for the exceptional gifted. I have a really good friend with aspergers syndrome who has as slightly higher IQ (190's) than mine. He is very well liked but his perception of reality is quite distorted due to his hindrance, unfortunately high IQ is many times coupled with some other form of mental or physical impairment, there are a lot of theories as to why this is, but sufficient to say not all of them are a joy. My point being these impairments are usually the target of ridicule at formative points in an intelligent persons life and some times bitters them from the pursuit of their potential and in extreme cases like my friend bitters them from helping better mankind at all.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by huherto on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @01:11PM (#1162061)
Being the smartest man in world(or at least) can be a big burden. Can you imagine that? Every body expecting you too be perfect; every little sentence you make analyzed; everybody trying to see how smart you really are; everybody trying to prove that they are smarter than you; everybody criticizing that you haven't contributed more. Being the smarter man in the world was given to you; you didn't ask for it. Besides, there are plenty of things that are important, and intelligence should be also about living a full filling life.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by python123 on Monday March 01, 2010 @03:29PM (#1159674)
Quit trying to suck up to the people on here. They are not talented people. This would be obvious to you if you had any talent at all. These people are mostly 30-some career software engineers who fantasize about becoming entrepreneurs and like thinking of themselves as hackers even though they lack the skills to justify that term. There's some good domain technical knowledge here, but very little actual intelligence. Just read any math links (everybody upvotes to look good, but nobody comments because they don't really understand - or they write really dumb comments).

If you can read Outliers and not understand the horrible science and generalizations behind it then you are an idiot. 120 IQ?? Are you kidding me? Maybe it makes you feel better because you only have a 120 IQ, but that precludes you from achieving anything meaningful in math and science. High IQ does not mean you will be a high achiever, but only those with exception IQ's are able to achieve in certain fields.

This is the problem with America. This is why America will lose to China in the next decades. We are trained to feel better about ourselves be devaluing those with superior intellect and ability.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by bitwize on Monday March 01, 2010 @03:48PM (#1159719)
Would that you could tell that to Feynman (I.Q. 127). His amused smile at your remarks would probably be one for the ages.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by gwern on Thursday April 08, 2010 @06:02PM (#1251164)
Gleick's bio actually puts it at 125. There are a couple reasons to not care about this factoid:

- Feynman was younger than 15 when he took it, and very near this factoid in Gleick's bio, he recounts Feynman asking about very basic algebra (2^x=4) and wondering why anything found it hard - the IQ is mentioned immediately before the section on 'grammar school', or middle school, implying that the 'school IQ test' was done well before he entered high school, putting him at much younger than 15. (15 is important because Feynman had mastered calculus by age 15, Gleick says, so he wouldn't be asking his father why algebra is useful at age >15.) - Given that Feynman was born in 1918, this implies the IQ test was done around 1930 or earlier. Given that it was done by the New York City school district, this implies also that it was one of the 'ratio' based IQ tests - utterly outdated and incorrect by modern standards. - Finally, it's well known that IQ tests are very unreliable in childhood; kids can easily bounce around compared to their stable adult scores.

So, it was a bad test, which even under ideal circumstances is unreliable & prone to error, and administered in a mass fashion and likely not by a genuine psychometrician.

As the saying goes, the plural of anecdote is not data, and this isn't even a very good anecdote. (I charitably assume that Feynman isn't joking here about the score; Gleick gives no source.)

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by python123 on Monday March 01, 2010 @04:02PM (#1159763)
That only means IQ tests are utter bullcrap. I'm talking about real intelligence. Feynman was an extremely gifted mathematician from a very early age. He won lots of math awards and was even a Putnam Fellow. Those are far more legitimate tests of his intelligence than whatever garbage exam produced his 127. It's good you take a single example and try to generalize without looking at any other facts. Sure, most people with 120 IQs can win Putnam or go on to become great physicists.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by Confusion on Monday March 01, 2010 @04:31PM (#1159832)
If you are going to argue something while insulting the intelligence of the community you are trying to convince, at least make sure you have a clear and consistent argument to make. You're currently contradicting yourself, by first claiming

  [..] only those with exception IQ's are able to achieve in certain fields
while you now claim

  IQ tests are utter bullcrap
If you confuse the terms intelligence and IQ, any arguments concerning the difference become very unconvincing.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by pw0ncakes on Monday March 01, 2010 @04:49PM (#1159878)
I don't think there's an IQ test out there that can reliably distinguish 1M:1 ("175") intelligence from 1000:1 ("147"), but it definitely exists and, in some pursuits, it matters. I know because I'm in the 1-10k:1 range and I know some 1M:1 people (IMO gold medalists, Putnam fellows) and, although they aren't so different as to live in a separate world, they're clearly smarter.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by python123 on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:56PM (#1160194)
Ummm..... wouldn't such a test be something like Putnam or IMO? As you said, those exact tests that let us distinguish at that level.
Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by python123 on Monday March 01, 2010 @07:55PM (#1160305)
@pw0ncakes

This just shows that IQ tests are garbage. Top level math contests are a much better indicator of your intelligence. I don't know what tests you're talking about because USAMO and Putnam don't have internationals.

And what mathematicians are you talking about? Take time to look them up because I can think of no examples of great mathematicians being "bad at proofs". That would mean they were bad at logic, which would mean they were bad at math. Being more famous for a conjecture doesn't mean you were bad at proofs. To even produce those conjecture requires deep understanding of the math leading to it. I can almost guarantee that there are no great mathematicians who would zero Putnam. I don't even zero Putnam, and there are plenty of people way better than me who still have no chance of becoming a great mathematician.

Do you realize how brilliant a mathematician has to be for you to even ever know his name?

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by pw0ncakes on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @10:43AM (#1161616)
International students can take Putnam if they go to school in the US, no? I could be wrong on this.

And what mathematicians are you talking about? I retract that: "sucked at proofs" is too strong a statement. There was a time when the same degree of rigor wasn't expected, so a lot of great mathematicians never or rarely wrote proofs. An example would be Ramanujan, who contributed immensely to mathematics and had amazing intuition, but who rarely wrote proofs and, when he did, Hardy usually had to fill in the holes.

On the other hand, had Ramanujan desired or needed to learn how to write rigorous proofs, there's no doubt that he would have been able to do so.

As for Putnam as a "better indicator" of intelligence than IQ tests, I'd agree, but it still only measures one kind of intelligence. The problem with IQ tests is that they aren't accurate in the upper ranges (140+) because that's not what they're designed for.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by pw0ncakes on Monday March 01, 2010 @07:37PM (#1160285)
First of all, you can study for those (although virtually all of us hit a ceiling because those problems are very hard). I used to study for those tests (although technically not IMO since I never qualified for it) and did reasonably well, although my IQ is "only" about 150. If these tests were perfect IQ tests, I shouldn't have even placed in the top thousand... since there are 400-4000 Americans smarter than me per year, plus the international students. (However, my "math IQ" if such a thing could be measured would probably be around 165-170, and "verbal IQ" around 135-140.)

Also, there are a couple of famous mathematicians (names don't come to mind) who are notorious for sucking at proofs. Their conjectures were very good and almost always right, but they relied on future mathematicians to prove their work (details, details). They would likely zero the Putnam.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by rictic on Monday March 01, 2010 @07:52PM (#1160300)
"Maybe it makes you feel better because you only have a 120 IQ, but that precludes you from achieving anything meaningful in math and science."

Child prodigy and Fields Medalist Terry Tao disagrees: http://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/does-one-have-to...

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by python123 on Monday March 01, 2010 @10:29PM (#1160520)
LOL. I love this example. An absolute genius looks at his own work and thought process to conclude that one does not need to be a 'genius' in order to succeed in math. It's difficult for someone that brilliant to understand that while the things he does may seem ordinary, they are far beyond the reach of the vast majority of human beings.

And he's trying to convince the people who were only Putnam honorable mentions or whatever not to give up on math. This has nothing to do with people with a 120 IQ (I know IQ is a BS measure, but when people say 120 IQ, they mean someone who is above-average, but modestly so).

I wonder what Terry Tao's definition of genius is. Would he consider himself a genius? Everybody else would. But he might not.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by Confusion on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @03:50AM (#1160925)
It's difficult for someone that brilliant to understand that while the things he does may seem ordinary, they are far beyond the reach of the vast majority of human beings.

Right, so on the hand, he's brilliant and understand both things that are ordinary and things that are extraordinary, but when it comes to somewhat softer knowledge, suddenly his genius is a reason for him to not understand something. Luckily we have you to explain that to him and us...</below the waist, but you are really, really asking for it>

Tao is a genius that teaches other people how to do math and we may well assume that he understands what it requires. He has probably taught dozen of students and according to him, they could be people that score 120 on an IQ test and yet succeed at math.

Finally, if only geniuses could succeed at math, most Ph.D. students would not count as successful, despite advancing the science. You're redefining 'success' to suit your needs and you're doing the same thing with other facts: bending their ambiguity to support your thesis, instead of basing your thesis on a single interpretation of the facts.

Re:Kim Ung-yong: The man with the highest IQ by DaniFong on Monday March 01, 2010 @06:36PM (#1160151)
There are many happy ways to live, but to each their own.

I wrote an essay on my experience, a bit of a similar topic.

http://daniellefong.com/2008/05/15/advice-to-the-bright-and-...