Re:SpaceX plans to debut Red Dragon with 2018 Mars mission
by rwmj on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:40PM
(#11583835)
Don't underestimate the power of a large boulder dropped into the earth's gravity well.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:SpaceX plans to debut Red Dragon with 2018 Mars mission
by madaxe_again on Thursday April 28, 2016 @06:36AM
(#11587725)
Yeah, but also don't underestimate the power needed to get it there in the first place. Earth would have a fully fledged industrial complex, the ability to lob nukes across space. A burgeoning Mars colony would still be worrying about producing enough water to survive - launching boulders, or even carving chunks off phobos to fling back at earth - neither are easy prospects, and given that a nuke could make the journey in weeks (big rockets, don't care about slowing down), you wouldn't have much time to do anything other than hunker down and wait for fire.
Re:SpaceX plans to debut Red Dragon with 2018 Mars mission
by rwmj on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:36AM
(#11587998)
I thought it was a bit unfair that your comment above was downvoted, so I upvoted it. Anyway, the canonical "reference" is Kim Stanley-Robinson's "Red Mars" :-) In that book independence happens after the Mars colony has reached a sufficient level of development.
Re:SpaceX plans to debut Red Dragon with 2018 Mars mission
by oxymoron on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:47PM
(#11585218)
The moon is a harsh mistress, indeed.
Re:SpaceX plans to debut Red Dragon with 2018 Mars mission
by vkou on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:49AM
(#11586924)
If you feasibly want to move it, it would have to be a very large boulder. You would have to plan your redirect years in advance.
For anything a martian colony could realistically move in a shorter timescale, even if it hit Manhattan, it might kill a few thousand people.
A much smaller boulder dropped into the Martian gravity well would kill the entire colony.