I have seen statistics before about how having a degree positively influences your earnings potential, but I have yet to see anything but "feelings" from those claiming going to college has a negative effect.
If we're going on anecdotes, I seriously doubt I could have made that much going into work straight out of high school, and I seriously doubt there are many people that could.
I would bet there's a more people that could qualify for significant scholarships than could make significant money going straight into work.
For most people staying in school is probably a good idea. But, when your options are to stay in school or drop out and make 70+k / year staying in school seems less useful. Would these people make more money in 5 years with a collage degree well possibly, but they are making good money now and investments compound with time so it would have to be a huge increase to be worth it.
PS: Doctors get paid a lot latter in life but on average they don’t retire younger than most people.
Finally, you could get significant returns if you invested your first years tuition by the end of 5 years.