ya my co-founder is the same way too, he love coffee for coffee's sake. The smell, relaxation, break, etc.
Me on the other hand for whatever reason don't feel like that when I drink coffee. I'm almost doing it purely for the caffeine dose. Energy drinks, 5 hour energy shots, pills, whatever just to get some more caffeine.
I should probably lower my caffeine intake though.. I like the 1/2 coffee 1/2 decaf suggestion above. I'll try that tomorrow!
If you don't like the taste of that (decaf tastes bad to me) or just want more control over your intake, caffeine pills aren't a terrible way to go as a temporary solution.
Figure out how much caffeine you usually drink, and take that much with no liquid caffeine for a couple of days and make sure you're ok with that. Then slowly lower your dose until skipping only leaves you with a mild headache or none at all.
By that I mean that a key part of my coffee experience is actually making (or walking to) the cup of joe. It's a brief break in my day where I can focus on something else, clearing my head even momentarily. Similarly, the act of drinking a coffee over ten minutes slows me down, allowing me to refocus on the task/s at hand. Popping pills might provide the same amount of caffeine, but in taking away that experience would detract from my coffee outcomes.