News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by Blackthorn on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:08PM (#11575164)
I've made the claim in the past on, for example, my FB feed that American drone strikes are literally terrorism and should be treated no differently than (for example) the Brussels attacks. This has resulted in more than a few hurt feelings but honestly I cannot see a difference. I am American.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by jeremyt on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:11PM (#11575193)
You can't see any difference between an attack in an extremely public place that indiscriminately targets civilians in an effort to kill as many people as possible and targeted attacks on specific targets with sometimes unfortunate and unavoidable collateral damage?
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by wfunction on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:17PM (#11575253)
That's like saying "you can't see any difference between killing 10 people and killing 100 people"? Uh, sure I do, but doesn't mean that necessarily means you have to treat them differently. There are a practically infinite number of variations on how murder can be done but they're all murder. And in our case, they're all terrorism. Doesn't mean you need an infinite number of consequences for them.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by noir_lord on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:13PM (#11575209)
> unavoidable collateral damage?

It isn't unavoidable, don't fire the damn missiles from the Drone.

The US and UK are like a little kid who fucks with a hornets nest, gets stung and retaliates by getting a flamethrower.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by jeremyt on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:15PM (#11575229)
If you are against any use of force which could have collateral damage, then you are effectively against any use of force. That's a principled stand, but not actually very realistic.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by rl3 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:36PM (#11575408)
There's a difference between being against any use of force that could have collateral damage, and firing anti-tank missiles into populated areas. The former is tragic, the latter is sheer stupidity.

Fortunately weaponized lasers are coming. Those should succeed in reducing collateral damage almost entirely. All that needs fixing after that is the often-faulty intelligence, and weeding out gung-ho idiot drone operators.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by noir_lord on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:21PM (#11575297)
No, I'm against any use of force that isn't clearly self defence.

(Very Very hypothetically) Russia annexes half of western Europe and starts massing troops on the border and deploying landing craft then you can open fire.

It's not very realistic purely because of the way the world currently works, as Von Clausewitz said "War is the continuation of diplomacy by other means" and it shouldn't be.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by oarsinsync on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @09:35AM (#11580262)
> the human rights group Reprieve has confirmed this reality vividly, finding that, in Pakistan, in attempts to take out 41 men, American drones actually killed an estimated 1,147 people (while not all of the 41 targeted figures even died). In other words, this hasn’t proved to be a war on terror, but a war of terror

If that is true, then it's not "could have", it's "almost definitely will".

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by Blackthorn on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:16PM (#11575239)
I'd have agreed with you completely on that if it wasn't for the drone strike on the wedding. Once that happened I could no longer call these strikes specifically targeted attacks.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by gldalmaso on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:21PM (#11575299)
> unavoidable collateral damage

First responders and funerals are unavoidable collateral damage?

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by the-dude on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#11575205)
I do not see why intention matters.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by strictnein on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:13PM (#11575215)
Motive is important in how we judge almost everything in life. Why would this be any different?
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by the-dude on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:18PM (#11575263)
Is that so? I am not sure. Also this leads to 'I hit you because I love you' excuses.

And that is all they are, excuses.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by delecti on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:23PM (#11575312)
Motive matters, but it isn't the final word.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by jeremyt on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:17PM (#11575249)
A scientist attempting to find a cure for cancer accidentally mixes up some chemicals and causes a huge explosion which results in 1000 deaths. Alternately, a terrorist sets off a bomb in a public place killing 1000 people.

Should they each be charged with the same crime and receive the same punishment?

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by Jtsummers on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:29PM (#11575345)
Your scientist had no intent on killing anyone. Drone strikes are intended to kill. It's an unapt comparison for a discussion about two groups deliberately killing people. One classified as "terrorism" and the other classified as "war as usual/collateral damage" when they kill innocent people.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by jeremyt on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:53PM (#11576027)
I was responding to a comment stating "I don't see why intention matters"
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by cam_l on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @10:31PM (#11577458)
Not if you assume punishment is the appropriate response to a crime. But if you think a mixture of public safety, admonishment, and rehabilitation is the better response, then yes probably.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by thesimpsons1022 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:19PM (#11575275)
I don't think that is the best example. It can be as simple as someone intentionally running over a cat versus backing out and not noticing it.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by thesimpsons1022 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:17PM (#11575252)
intention is all that matters.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by sean-duffy on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:13PM (#11575207)
For a start, the drone strikes are at least claimed to be against strategic targets and not just indiscriminate killing of civilians. That's something that can't be said for the likes of the Brussels attacks.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by _delirium on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:16PM (#11575237)
That's true for some, but not all things usually classified as terrorism. For example the IRA bomb aimed at Margaret Thatcher, with other people being collateral damage, was considered a terrorist attack at the time, even though its goal wasn't to indiscriminately kill civilians. The Greek group 17 November is another example, which exclusively carried out targeted assassinations (their first success was killing the Athens CIA station chief). The term is a bit fuzzy, though, so quite a few different kinds of attacks get grouped under it depending when and who we're talking about.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:30PM (#11575355)
It's only terrorism when "they" do it. That's basically the working definition.

Same goes with war crimes; cf. the U.S. attack on the Doctors Without Borders hospital in Kunduz, 2015. No matter what the facts are in that case, the U.S. is never going to admit responsibility for a war crime. Blaming the pilots for "human error", no consequences for any commanding officers, is the path they will take.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by nekomancer on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:31PM (#11575361)
The Brussels atttacks were against strategic targets though.

As for the indiscriminate killing of civilians, what else would you call the example from the article?

> in Pakistan, in attempts to take out 41 men, American drones actually killed an estimated 1,147 people (while not all of the 41 targeted figures even died).

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by Jtsummers on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:18PM (#11575268)
The Brussels attacks had no specific individuals being targeted.

Drone strikes that hit civilians and a specific target are sloppy assassinations, and terrorism.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by calgoo on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:26PM (#11575328)
To the terrorists the big public places are also strategic targets. They are the underdog so to make the most noise they involve a lot of civilians.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by kuschku on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:37PM (#11575896)
Well, one of the Brussels attacks happened right next to the some of the EU buildings – that’s more targeted than most drone strikes.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by ybrah on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:22PM (#11575304)
One can argue that the civilians killed at the Brussels terror attacks are actually strategic targets for the terror groups.
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by snowwrestler on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:37PM (#11575417)
I think a lot of Americans would object to that, in part because our drone strikes have very specific targets--they are not intended to cause general terror.

That said, from the perspective of people on the ground, there is no doubt that they are generally terrifying and horrifying. While the strikes might help degrade ISIS leadership and operations, they also help create extremely strong anti-US emotions by killing innocent men, women, and children.

The hard question is, what is the alternative? Ignore ISIS? That's dangerous. Put boots on the ground? Not going to happen--the American people are sick of that. So perhaps drone strikes are simply the least terrible of several terrible options.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by richmarr on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:47PM (#11575477)
> ... not intended to cause general terror.

Maybe, although it's hard to imagine there's no intent for drone strikes to act as a deterrent. It's not identical to idiomatic terrorism, but also not completely different.

> Ignore ISIS? That's dangerous.

There are no choices available here that aren't extremely dangerous. None. Least of all the cookie-cutter 'war hawk' attitudes that got us into this mess in the first place.

Personally my suspicion is that ignoring them is probably the least dangerous. ISIS is an organisation that feeds on radicalisation, it feeds on aggression. Aggression is its recruiting tool.

Build a mosque. Build a mosque so f%cking huge and beautiful that even hearing about it makes ISIS fighters weep.

Change the music and all this will be over in a few years. Feed the war machine and we're here for another generation at least.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by fweespee_ch on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:16PM (#11575241)
Employed properly, drone strikes against legitimate targets [e.g. Military bases, arms shipments] are perfectly reasonable and effective.

Really the only problem we have is the fact the US keeps using it as a tool of assassination which results in too much collateral damage:

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2014/nov/24/-sp-us-drone-...

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by hellbanner on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#11575204)
Thank you for doing this! It might help in your campaign to compare "terrorism" as the US media puts it, and George Bush's "Shock & Awe" campaign -- designed to intimidate and scare their enemy for a political purpose :)

That and the Bush's family relations with the Bin Laden family in the decades past.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by malandrew on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:38PM (#11575430)
Interesting comment.

It would be ironic if future videos claiming responsibility for violent attacks start using the exact same terms and language as the US politicians, such as "Shock & Awe".

When a major component of allowing a conflict to proceed is support or merely just apathy from the populace that has elected the leaders that are targeting your people, it would seem that the most effective way to highlight the hypocrisy of the elected leaders of your enemies would be to mirror their tactics as precisely as possible as opposed to escalation. Mirroring puts it in people's mind that they need to oppose further violence from their side to stop future attacks against themselves.

Sadly, the other side adopting a strict eye for an eye approach to retaliation (tit for tat) might be the only way that either side can actually avoid making the whole world blind, since it would at least promote dialogue where people on both sides at least ask themselves "When we commit X against them, they commit X against us. Maybe we should try to stop committing X and see if they will too". The current approach of planning out attacks that escalate the conflict just makes things worse.

I'm curious if there has been any solid game theory research into the impact of tit-for-tat retaliation versus escalating retaliation.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by hellbanner on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:30AM (#11589578)
The videogame nuclear-war simulator "Defcon" ran with the tagline "Everybody Dies": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGHC_aInRPE

and Civilization simulator ends up with the planet in nuclear-winter, 3 nation-states turning all resources into armies, forgoing peace treaties and maintaining borders via nuclear bombardment. https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/uxpil/ive_been_play...

---

The problem with disarmament, of course, is that if A disarms and B doesn't.. A is vulnerable to B.

After being robbed twice, a game developer & his wife seriously considered purchasing a guard dog or a firearm. They were very uncomfortable with the idea of escalation and wondered where it would end.

He built "The Castle Doctrine" -- a game where a man with a wife and kids spends his money fortifying his home against invaders, then invades other homes to take their treasure.. to spend on more fortifications.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYBrc8HpPIs (interview with the developer)

--

Not the scientific rigor you were asking for but an interesting exploration.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by clavalle on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:16PM (#11575244)
"political purpose" in this case meaning deterring people from attacking us.

I'm no fan of how Bush handled things but painting flying airliners filled with civilians into skyscrapers filled with civilians and hitting government and infrastructure targets after publicly declaring war with the same brush is ridiculous.

Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by hellbanner on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:25AM (#11589530)
Why is attacking civilians & government after declaring war "ridiculous" for the aggressor? Or am I misunderstanding your comment?
Re:We’re not the “good guys”: American drone warfare is terr... by clavalle on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:00PM (#11590292)
You misunderstood.

Attacking civilians is bad in any context and strictly illegal.

Declaring war then attacking government, military, and critical infrastructure after such a declaration is quite different from flying a plane of civilians into a civilian building out of nowhere. Equating the two is as disingenuous as comparing a loan shark beating someone for non-payment to someone getting evicted.