So redesigning from scratch, following strict clean room protocols (fresh designer who hasn't ever worked on the GPLed design, given a description only), defeats the GPL because it is based on copyright ?
Presumably no GPLed RepRap derived community innovations were copied, if they were ( hypothetically an amazing way of doing the nozzle or special hot-plate method to avoid warping ) would this demonstrate a derived work and trigger GPL ?
If this type of thing isn't a GPL trigger then why can't anyone clean room a different design of sintering tech and allow general sinter 3D printing and sales ?
Is this difference because the GPL relies on copyright but 3D sintering is patent protected ? If so does Open Hardware need a GPL patent license, can that even be possible ?
Has a hardware GPL case ever been brought ?
3d sintering is different because as you said, sintering is patented. Physical products have a bunch of rules that are significantly different from software products, and the area is really murky. I don't know of any GPL hardware cases, but would doubt they'd get very far unless you were able to show direct infringement, which is a lot harder.
Or I am off base and Bowyer's RepRap GPL only applies to media like blueprints ?
Or the Makerbot is sufficiently different ? Or there was prior art to Bowyer ?
The MakerBot derives from this GPLed work - the first MakerBot parts were printed by a RepRap.
This is a RepRap tradition that a RepRap print the parts for new RepRaps, a ceremonial self replication.
So the MakerBot's intellectual property is not wholly their own and in fact is derives from a GPL licensed work.
Is this a GPL violation or did MakerBot relicense the RepRap from Bath ?
Perhaps the MakerBot is a 'clean room' redesign of the RepRap, but Pettis, MakerBot's founder was involved from the beginning and built RepRaps and the the MakerBot designs evolution (and initial part printing) from the RepRap is well documented by Make magazine.
MakerBots not being GPL licensed seems like a GPL violation but IANAL.